News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is the industry saturated with data scientists al... by kevinfat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:12PM (#34101968)
I don't think that is correct. I don't think the market actually needs phd level stats skills. Its just like the market doesn't need phd level pure math or doesn't need phd level CS. The number of situations where these specialized knowledge is useful in industry is vanishingly small. Having a phd is more about being even considered for an interview for such a position. The actual day to day knowledge used will consist of topics that even a person with a bachelor could require without putting in years.
Re:Ask HN: Is the industry saturated with data scientists al... by burnished on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:37PM (#34102094)
They are saying that the thing you are talking about right now is saturated - but positions that authentically need that level of expertise are not.
Re:Ask HN: Is the industry saturated with data scientists al... by MontyCarloHall on Friday December 23, 2022 @12:02AM (#34102492)
Thanks for making my point more clearly than I did!

As an aside, regarding whether people actually do PhD-level math at these jobs, the answer is indeed often no. However, the jobs can still require PhD-level experience. This is because there is a lag between being able to merely learn concepts at a given level versus being able to actually synthesize those concepts to solve novel problems. It is relatively easy to learn a subject and solve exercises in that subject that you know pertain to the concepts you just studied, as you would encounter in a course. It is much harder to be given a problem out of the blue and realize what concepts are required to solve it, as you would encounter in a scientific career.

As a concrete example, I once was explaining neural networks to a bright college freshman. I showed him the forward pass equation, then asked him how he would optimize the network weights given said equation. Even though he learned the chain rule in his courses, he didn’t think to apply it to derive the backpropagation step. By contrast, a talented junior or senior can easily figure this out.

In my experience, the learning/synthesis gap is usually a few years. Hence, your average new PhD-level data scientist would be capable of synthesizing advanced undergraduate material towards solving novel problems in their job. And there are a hell of a lot of data science jobs that require that.