News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by sliken on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:26PM (#34100854)
Umm, not sure you understand. Yes AES256 is good, if you have a great password.

However if you take 1M users, as them to set a 12 character password with A-Z, a-z, and at least one digit you'll find an astounding lack of entropy. I believe this is pretty close to LastPass's master password requirements.

If you take the most popular 1M passwords and attack the master password you'll find that you've cracked them. With a 2 generation old GPU and the default iterations of 5000 (like several people mention on this post) you can try 300,000 passwords a second. So 3+ seconds per vault and you'd crack a decent fraction of them.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by jart on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:50PM (#34101432)
(26+10)**12 is 4738381338321616896 combinations. 300,000 attempts per second isn't going to have an easy time cracking that, so I don't see what the problem is with LastPass' requirements.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by mint2 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:12PM (#34101590)
“(26+10)*12” is irrelevant

Please Refer back to “If you take the most popular 1M passwords and attack the master password…”

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by jart on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:17PM (#34101626)
It is relevant, because it's where LastPass' responsibility ends. It's not their job to prevent people from being stupid and choosing a password like `lovelovel0ve` but rather to define a requirement that allows for sufficient complexity.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by rsj_hn on Saturday December 24, 2022 @02:55AM (#34114916)
I think a reasonable feature for a password manager would be to do NIST recommended checks, such as comparing passwords to databases of known compromised passwords and alerting/recommending rotation or rejection of the password if a match is found (depending on password entry UI).

Obviously you're not going to get a complete db of known hacks, but a db of most common X million passwords, updated every 6 months or so, is pretty good, and is what I would expect a good password manager to do.

LastPass is in the bad situation of needing to provide excellent security in a product that people really aren't willing to pay a lot of money for. Some of the websites that ask for passwords are in a better position to do this, but then you don't get the benefits of a password manager.

Same issue for the the other password managers out there.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by sliken on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:24PM (#34101666)
Yes, those with pure random passwords are safe. What percent of LastPass users do you think use a very hard to remember completely random 12+ character password?

Personally I use either VaultWardens random password generator, or some variation of the XKCD like 4-6 words out of 100,000 which give me somewhere north of 64-96 bits of entropy. Cracking that @ 300k/sec takes a quite long time. I like the XKCD approach, because it's particularly voice/phone friendly.

However much more common in the real world is to pick an easy to remember password with low entropy, something like PinkFloydRocks, which fail because of lack of a number and change it to P1nkFloydRocks. Or maybe PinkFloydRocks<2 digit birth year>.

Quite a few plaintext passwords have been leaked, some even with helpful popularity tables. I'd place bets that a decent percent of LastPass's vaults would fall to a top 10,000 12 character or longer popular passwords. I suspect someone is testing this right now.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by jart on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:46PM (#34101801)
I had a feeling you were speaking from experience with that 300k number. Does that include the cost of password stretching? As others have pointed out in this thread LastPass uses PBKDF2 with 100,000 rounds. Even if you have a supercharged PC with 6x ATI Radeon HD 5870 you're only going to be able to derive 25k AES keys per second tops to even try, since that doesn't include the cost of deciphering. So how do you do it?
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by sliken on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:10PM (#34101960)
No experience, just saw a post on someone attacking LastPass Vaults. It looked to include everything. Apparently they wrote a tool specifically attempting password recovery on LastPass vaults and with a RTX 2070 (2 generation old) managed 309,000 against the 5000 iteration flavor and 15,500 against the 100,100 flavor.

More info at: https://blog.elcomsoft.com/2020/04/breaking-lastpass-instant...

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by FatActor on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:17PM (#34102294)
First, where do I find the most popular one million 12-character passwords that use A-Z/a-z/0-9?

Second, the top 1M of 6/7/8 character passwords have a statistically higher probably of being the correct password than the top 1M of 62^12 because their distribution function as a percentage of possible instances is narrower. Put another way: the top 7 char password might be used 10 million times, and the 2nd most popular might be 9million, etc. With a 12 char password, the top 1 by nature appears much less frequency because the total possible space is larger and people have to think a little more. Entropy when that has nothing to do with inverse distributions.

Put another way, look at the frequency of the top-1 password as a sum of all instances of all 1M passwords. It is much larger % for smaller passwords than larger. It is much less likely that the top 1M 12-char passwords are as likely to be successful as the top 1M 6/7/8-char passwords.

I just did this for the top 1000 6/7/8 chhar passwords, the top 6 digit password "123456" represents 1.3% of all 1000 6-chars, where as "password" is 0.9% of all 1000 8-char.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by Eisenstein on Friday December 23, 2022 @12:56AM (#34102704)
> First, where do I find the most popular one million 12-character passwords that use A-Z/a-z/0-9?

I'm sure it may not be easy to find this database, but it is probably not that difficult if you hang out in the type of circles that the people who cracked that site hang out in.

> Math...

This strikes me as nitpicking when one can access such powerful computing devices as to make the difference practically irrelevant. So make it 10million and wait a few more minutes, who cares?

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by FatActor on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:08AM (#34102767)
How is it nitpicking? The distribution tail effectively goes to a frequency of zero. Increasing to 10M doesn't solve the problem because the space is so vast, by the time you get to a fraction that has the similar area under the curve as 1M for 6/7/8 chars, you've lost any compute advantage. We're not talking an order of magnitude, we're talking multiple. As much as I know y'all want to hate on any password manager that isn't your favorite, math doesn't care about what strikes you as nitpicking.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by Eisenstein on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:24AM (#34102841)
I don't use a password manager and am not familiar with the math involved; I was going off your 10million number and the post above you's 300,000 iterations/sec.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by FatActor on Friday December 23, 2022 @11:15AM (#34107392)
I'm trying to understand how Top-N frequency distribution flattens and becomes less useful as search space increases. It is a both a statistical and a psychological issue. If you can't help don't comment.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by Eisenstein on Friday December 23, 2022 @04:09PM (#34110645)
I think you might find that your life goes a little more smoothly if you weren't so abrasive, confrontational and dismissive. As a side affect, people you talk to won't end up feeling like shit because you possibly will treat them less terribly.
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by bawolff on Friday December 23, 2022 @10:33PM (#34113662)
> by the time you get to a fraction that has the similar area under the curve as 1M for 6/7/8 chars,

You are (incorrectly) conflating entropy of a password with its length.

> math doesn't care about what strikes you as nitpicking.

Math actually cares a lot about the nitpicky details. Both in the sense that small things can have big effects, but also in the sense that things which sound big can also be irrelavent.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by slenk on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:11PM (#34131315)
Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by sliken on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:07AM (#34102765)
There's been tons of dumps posted. Normally I see the download or magnet links on Reddit or HN. Even with hashes people have broken 69% [0] to 85% [1] of the accounts. There's mailing list or forums for various related tools (cracking tools, gpu cracking, have I been pwned, etc.) that discuss these kinds of things, including where to get the passwords and/or hashes.

One of the summaries claimed that 3% of the cracked passwords were 12 characters long (some 1.9M). 48% of the cracked passwords were lower case and numbers.

Often a thread that mentions the compromise/leak also mentions the newest "batch" that includes the new entries. The last one I tracked was RockYou2021.txt, some 100GB, around 10GB compressed. Just use your favorite egrep/perl/python to filter for whatever you want. I checked the a random torrent and found 25 people on it.

I agree on your comments on the distribution, but the average user has shockingly little entropy, and human password entropy doesn't scale with password length. I expect a decent chunk of the passwords are going to be whatever the user's default password was and either repeating or extending it in obvious ways. Even the simplest approach of testing 2 words or 3 words for a total 12-15 characters with the simple 3/E i/one and 7/L replacements would likely. Granted I'm not expecting the same 8 character 69-85% with 12 characters, but I also don't expect much significantly less, and I believe 33M accounts were stolen.

[0] https://blog.korelogic.com/blog/2016/05/19/linkedin_password... [1] https://www.trustedsec.com/blog/introduction-gpu-password-cr...

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by sliken on Saturday December 24, 2022 @07:23PM (#34122704)
rockyou2021.txt.7z has 8459060239 passwords rockyou2021.txt.7z has 835365123 that are 12 characters long pwned-passwords has 847223402 unique password hashes pwned-passwords has 5579399834 non-unique passwords hashes

I'm amused that each password was reused on average 6.5 times.

I suspect large fraction of the pwned-passwords hashes could be turned into passwords with the rockyou2021 list.

Re:LastPass: Notice of Recent Security Incident by bawolff on Friday December 23, 2022 @03:02AM (#34103374)
> First, where do I find the most popular one million 12-character passwords that use A-Z/a-z/0-9?

A good starting place is https://github.com/danielmiessler/SecLists/tree/master/Passw...

> Second, the top 1M of 6/7/8 character passwords have a statistically higher probably of being the correct password than the top 1M of 62^12 because their distribution function as a percentage of possible instances is narrower.

Not how this works. This would only be true if you were picking passwords randomly out of all possible ones. "password" is a more common password than "cat" is (both are terrible of course). It doesn't matter that "password" is longer than "cat".

Once you get past the most common passwords it might happen to be true, but there is no reason it is neccesarily true.