Re:France fines Microsoft €60M for imposing advertising cookies
by jefftk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:27PM
(#34097388)
Before this decision I think using the same cookie for both inessential and essential purposes was something that many people still thought was okay, as long as (as Microsoft claimed they were doing) when you do not have permission to use the cookie for inessential purposes you only use it for essential purposes.
But yes, this all ended up being irrelevant since the court decided that they were using it for non-essential purposes before getting permission.
They tried to be clever by re-using the same cookie for multiple purpose essential and non-essential (the “essential” purpose being related to ad fraud detection) so they claimed they did not need consent to set the cookie. And since they argued that they chose to use a single cookie “to reduce the number of reads and writes”, which is bullshit, they were clearly not acting in any kind of good faith here. The regulator did not condemn them for the bad faith argument though, but because “ad fraud detection doesn't qualify as essential”, so their “smart” move of mixing essential and non-essential purposes within the same cookie wasn't even properly done…
> En outre, le rapporteur précise, en réponse à l’argumentation de la société considérant la finalité de lutte contre la fraude au sens large comme une finalité essentielle exemptée de consentement, que seule la finalité de lutte contre les attaques en déni de service pourrait être exemptée de consentement. Le rapporteur relève que les autres finalités évoquées ne relèvent pas du champ des exemptions prévues par l’article 82 de la loi Informatique et Libertés puisqu’elles n’ont pas vocation à faciliter une communication électronique et ne sont pas strictement nécessaires à la fourniture d’un service expressément demandé par l’utilisateur.