News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by crazygringo on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:40AM (#34082949)
This article is totally ignoring the existence of academic "handbooks", which is where the wisdom lies.

The whole idea is that individual papers are supposed to be exploratory, throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks. They're supposed to be a deluge of information.

But then every decade or so a team of academics take it upon themselves to serve as editors to a handbook, which attempts to survey the field in terms of history, where the most value has been found so far (and what hasn't panned out), and current promising directions. Usually something like 20-50 chapters, each contributed by a different author.

If you want to get into the wisdom of a field, the first thing you do is pull out the most recent 800-page handbook, read the first few chapters, and then drill down in your area of interest on the remaining part.

To say there "are no prizes for wisdom" is absurd, when being selected to publish in a handbook (or being an editor) is prestigious, a mark that you've very much "made it" in the field.

And of course there are plenty of other things that serve similar roles, such as literature review papers or similar. (In philosophy you can write a Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy article, for instance.)

If you aren't finding wisdom anywhere, it means you're simply not looking right.

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by yamrzou on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:58AM (#34083204)
Maybe the article is highlighting the fact that scientific papers are more accessible to the general public than handbooks: You can easily find academic papers on Arxiv or Google Scholar, newspapers cite them, etc. While handbooks don't get much publicity.
Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by aiwv on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:03PM (#34083271)
Not only have I never heard of this kind of "handbook" (in spite of having an advanced degree), it isn't clear to me how they actually would be a reliable source of wisdom. It sounds like they are supposed to be a meta-analysis of the current state field, but to take it up a meta-level, who is analyzing the meta-analysis? How do I know the editors didn't just select their friends who have similar viewpoints? In the abstract, a handbook seems as likely to send me wildly astray as it is to send me down the right path. Almost by design, I'd naively expect handbooks to amplify the status quo and discourage more radical ideas (as most institutions are wont to do). This might be good or bad depending on the status quo but either way I'm likely only going to get out wisdom proportional to what I bring in.
Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by crazygringo on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:20PM (#34083482)
Well, how do you reliably trust anything?

I've never seen a handbook that led anyone "wildly astray". They're put out by major academic publishers (Oxford, Routledge, etc.) who hire (publishing) editors qualified to select qualified (academic) editors to select qualified chapter contributors. It's not like they're randos self-publishing or something.

The entire point is to be a fairly neutral, comprehensive state of whatever field or subfield the handbook covers. And they generally do a pretty good job. A place like Oxford is never going to publish a handbook that's trying to push some ideological agenda and ignoring half the field.

But if you don't trust the senior editors at major academic presses, then I don't know what to tell you.

And since you've never heard of handbooks, see my peer comment with links so you can see they exist. :)

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by Tainnor on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:28PM (#34083602)
If there are different schools within a field, every one of them might have a handbook (so you might have a handbook on linguistic typology, and on the other hand a handbook on generative grammar - although often the topics are even more narrow), so they still are useful to get a survey of the land even when there are different schools of thought. I also do not at all share your sense that all science is crazy antagonistic and political in the sense that "institutions discourage radical ideas" - maybe that's true of some fields, but definitely not all of them (for example, the idea makes no sense at all for mathematics). Even when different opinions and schools of thought exist that doesn't necessarily mean that there's nothing that people can agree on.

But more concretely, you can just look up the authors that contributed to the handbook and if you do indeed have a degree in the field, you'll probably recognise them and their affiliations and will be able to know (or at least look up) what tradition they belong to and what this implies for the handbook.

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by marcosdumay on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:29PM (#34083632)
Is that advanced degree an academic oriented one or industry oriented?

People on the academic oriented degrees tend to use them a lot. But industry oriented degrees tend to stick with textbooks. (By the way, yes, textbooks are the other kind where you can find wisdom. Normally in an easier to get, more condensed form, but of an older kind.)

About who selects the books, well, who tells you if a book is any good? Some have very radical untested ideas, others stick to older but proven ones. You decide what book to get.

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by adamsmith143 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:33PM (#34086031)
>People on the academic oriented degrees tend to use them a lot.

Are you from the EU? Becuase having been in US STEM graduate programs in 2 different fields I have never come across such a handbook or know anyone who has. It's certainly not common in the US.

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by NhanH on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:04PM (#34083274)
Could you please give some examples of handbooks in some fields? I have read survey papers but this is the first time I’ve heard about the handbook concept
Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by crazygringo on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:07PM (#34083327)
Routledge and Oxford are major publishers. Browse to your heart's content:

https://www.routledgehandbooks.com/home

https://academic.oup.com/pages/oxford-handbooks

One I've read cover-to-cover, for example, is the OUP Handbook of Political Science:

https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/35474

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by grahar64 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:50PM (#34083946)
If I am doing academic study the fastest way to find good information is to find couple recent studies and cross match their references for common citations.

This often ends up in summary papers, foundational papers and papers with well founded experiments. The fact as a society we pay for millions of researchers to do (mostly) research is a resource many people ignore.

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by yamtaddle on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:00PM (#34086940)
You can pull this trick with academic books, too. If you find such a work in some niche subfield you know little about, but aren't sure that book's a good place to start, odds are good the author will name-drop most of the really important books & authors in the introduction. If you do this with two or three and cross-reference, any mentioned in more than one is probably something you ought to look at.
Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by earthicus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:28PM (#34084438)
I agree with you that academic summary works are probably the best way for a non-researcher to learn what exists, what's known (and what isn't). Since i've never seen them discussed or referenced on this website, let me also point out the existence of academic encyclopedias, such as the Springer encyclopedia of algoriths[1] (each entry is essentially a slightly more pedagogical review article about a subfield or important problem in CS, along with loads of references to the literature for digging deeper), and the delightful encyclopedia of distances [2](800 pages long!). A couple others i've seen that may be of interest to this audience are the encyclopedia of systems and control[3], and the encyclopedia of unconventional computing[4]

Unfortunately some of these are absurdly expensive, so if you don't want to go the piracy route the cheapest way to access some of them is to get a membership to your local public university's library system, which in the US typically costs like $100 a year or something.

[1] https://link.springer.com/referencework/10.1007/978-1-4939-2...

[2] https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-662-52844-0

[3] https://link.springer.com/referencework/10.1007/978-3-030-44...

[4] https://link.springer.com/referencework/10.1007/978-1-4939-6...

Re:We are drowning in information while starving for wisdom ... by kashyapc on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:57PM (#34086287)
An example[1] of these academic 800+ pager "handbooks" from Neuroscience:

"Cognitive Neuroscience: The Biology of the Mind" by Gazzaniga et al.

I don't own a physical copy of it yet (only digital), but I do have a copy of an equally outstanding book[2] called "Neuroscience: Exploring the Brain" by Bear et al. An excellent thing about this book is that each chapter has a small section called "Path to Discovery" where leading researchers on a given topic (including Nobel winners such as Eric Kandel) briefly share their story of how they arrived at their discoveries. Another excellent aspect of this book is its rich set of visual illustrations of complex topics. It makes learning a joy. I find their high price justified.

[1] https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393603170

[2] https://www.jblearning.com/catalog/productdetails/9781284211...