News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by zitterbewegung on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:56AM (#34080096)
Yes, that's the point. Apple ties you into its ecosystem by creating apps that only work on their platform and in this case pressuring your friends to also buy from them. This isn't anything new. This app isn't trivial to create so it has to be funded by them somehow. If another company created an app similar to this then they would follow probably a different pattern which would be to first release on iOS, pay for it by some subscription model and then eventually have an option on Android if the company doesn't get bought out by Apple / Android or get Sherlocked.
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by reeeeee on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:18AM (#34080326)
What does "getting Sherlocked" mean?
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by rubyfan on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:25AM (#34080408)
From wikipedia…

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherlock_(software)

Advocates of Watson made by Karelia Software, LLC claim that Apple copied their product without permission, compensation, or attribution in producing Sherlock 3. Some disagree with this claim, stating that Sherlock 3 was the natural evolution of Sherlock 2, and that Watson was obviously meant to have some relation to Sherlock by its very name.

The phenomenon of Apple releasing a feature that supplants or obviates third-party software is so well known that being Sherlocked has become an accepted term used within the Mac and iOS developer community.

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by jameshart on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:30AM (#34080464)
Usually something to do with running a tumblr full of Benedict Cumberbatch/Martin Freeman fanfic.

But in this case, it refers to the fact that there used to be a Mac app called Watson (made by Karelia Software) that let you search all your personal files. Then Apple added an OS feature called Sherlock that did the same thing and ripped the rug out from under the third party developer. (Sherlock has since been replaced by Spotlight in more recent MacOS versions)

By analogy, anyone making software in the Mac ecosystem (or any ecosystem really) risks being ‘Sherlocked’ by having their idea ripped off and turned into an OS feature.

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by a4isms on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:20AM (#34081033)
Calling it ”sherlocked” is recency bias on our part. Apple learned it from Microsoft, who took a thing that happened from time to time and operationalized it into a full-blown business strategy.

One by one, Microsoft took aim at successful DOS and Windows applications, especially business applications, and displaced them. Lotus… WordPerfect… Everyone, really. Unless your app was for a niche too specialized to be worth the hassle, Microsoft wanted to use you for market research and then either buy you, buy your competitor, or clone you.

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by kergonath on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:08AM (#34082499)
> Calling it ”sherlocked” is recency bias on our part.

It has been called “sherlocking” in the Mac sphere ever since the Sherlock 3 incident. Any bias is not on our part, as this was more than 20 years ago. Yes, some of us were there (I was, so maybe I share some responsibility), but the combination of the minuscule Mac market share at the time and its steady growth for the 2 following decades means that the people who were around at the time are a statistically insignificant fraction of us today.

It is not unique and in retrospect we can find many historical examples before that, but it was a particularly high-profile one, it made a lot of noise, and the name stuck. Also, most Mac users at this point avoided Windows (or eve worse, dog forbid, MS-DOS) like the plague so this would not have been in people’s minds.

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by a4isms on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:12PM (#34084238)
We may be of similar vintage, not only do I remember first-hand how Microsoft was feared in those days, one question every startup had to answer was, “Ok, this looks like it could be a hit. What is your plan for dealing with Microsoft if they choose to clone you or buy your competitor and give it away/put the night of their marketing, sales and distribution network behind driving you into bankruptcy?”

One other way in which the times have changed is that while all the platform monopolists will clone your app and bake it into the platform if they think it’s really a platform feature (remember when flashlight apps were a thing?), if they can get 30% of your revenue from their App Store, that is often good enough for them.

p.s. Now that I think about it, I wrote a really old-school bloviating blog post about this nearly 30 years ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=304718

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by zitterbewegung on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:12PM (#34087632)
If you really want to go back we could say both Apple and Microsoft Sherlocked Xerox PARC… at the same time.
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by lowbloodsugar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:55PM (#34089598)
So they, er xeroxed Xerox?
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by zitterbewegung on Friday December 23, 2022 @11:01AM (#34107204)
:) That's a better term.
Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by a4isms on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:14AM (#34090382)
When accused by Steve Jobs of ripping Apple’s technology and designs off, Bill Gates is said to have cooly replied:

"Well, Steve, I think there's more than one way of looking at it. I think it's more like we both had this rich neighbor named Xerox and I broke into his house to steal the TV set and found out that you had already stolen it."

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by ofcrpls on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:23AM (#34080385)
Long-form answer with a story from the dev who got Sherlocked first

https://www.karelia.com/blog/the-long-story-behind-karel.htm...

Re:Apple launches Freeform: a powerful new app designed for ... by GeekyBear on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:12PM (#34086456)
Microsoft Teams being preinstalled with the OS and set to automatically start when the OS boots would be an example.

There were several other options to do the same thing, but Microsoft added their own that came with the OS.