News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance by yummyfajitas on Friday December 30, 2011 @10:26AM (#3407870)
In practice, this means "standardized test scores." Does anyone actually think that's a good metric

If it isn't, we've got bigger problems - specifically the fact that we have no ability whatsoever to evaluate whether a school is doing a good job.

In that case, we need to fix our measurement process and waste as little money on unproven methods in the meantime.

Among other things, it turns out there's a lot of fluctuation of how much "value" a teacher adds from year to year.

If this is due to statistical noise, then teacher evaluation needs to be done on a multi-year basis. If this is due to internal variation in teacher quality, then maybe we need to either control the variation or accept that teacher quality varies widely and is mostly out of our control.

Note that if VAM doesn't work, then all the statistical studies claiming to show that teacher quality matters for student achievement are bunk. All those studies make some attempt at VAM, and show the variation due to teacher quality is large. Are you asserting that this is the case?

There are no comments on this comment yet.