News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by bob1029 on Monday December 19, 2022 @08:58PM (#34060595)
HFR movies never worked on my eyes, and I'm the kind of person who can instantly tell when windows sets my monitor back to 60hz from 144hz.

It feels like the lower frame rate engages the imagination in deeper ways than HFR. The obvious gaps in information are filled in by your brain in subtle ways. Yes, some types of action are almost certainly made better in an HFR setting, but then all other action has to go along for the ride.

If the experience is interactive, then yes by all means - Give me the most FPS you can. But when I don't have control, slow those picture elements down a bit. Give my neural net some time to deal with each one so I can properly enjoy it.

Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by HyperSane on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:38PM (#34061235)
24fps is a completely arbitrary standard that is really the lowest possible usable framerate to save on film costs. It makes no sense at all to still be using it in the age of digital cameras.
Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by joshspankit on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:09AM (#34066085)
You open the door to something interesting: variable frame rate films.. Personally I would love to see certain action scenes in 120+, and think there could be interesting artistic choices about when to change the frame time and how quickly...
Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by bob1029 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:58AM (#34068649)
I think you'd have a nightmare of a time getting this adopted into any standards body. Constant frame rate is so fundamental to a lot of pieces throughout.
Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by joshspankit on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:44PM (#34073863)
Definitely. Plus I suspect there are almost zero theatre projectors that could handle VFR
Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by jrockway on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:58PM (#34074032)
24 is a multiple of 120, so you can repeat frames 5x on the 24fps parts, and play the whole video at 120fps.

The question is what the on/off time is of a 24fps film. My TV has black frame insertion to make 24fps content look better; I am personally a huge fan of black frame insertion so I would imagine that theater projectors do it or something equivalent. If so, that will go away with your "play the same frame 5 times" algorithm. (Old style film projectors did it as an implementation detail; the sample and hold nature of LCD screens is a new "problem" for 24fps content.)

Info, and a demo, about black frame insertion: https://www.testufo.com/blackframes

Re:Avatar: The Way of Water Was Rendered in Amazon Web Services by joshspankit on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:31PM (#34076006)
That might work. Directors would easily have access to 24, 48, 72, 96, and 120fps