Re:AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating
by jacquesm on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:38PM
(#34058789)
> The fact some tests can be "cheated" by AI really just suggests that some skills have little to no value in our future AI-prevalent world.
That's like saying 'speech has no value'. It doesn't have value on its own, but if you can't speak then suddenly there is a whole pile of stuff you can no longer do. The ability to put your thoughts down in writing and to organize them into a hopefully coherent form is an act that has implications far beyond the writing itself. Besides the fact that it can help you to organize your thoughts in the process. Plenty of times when I write a longer piece I find out halfway that one or more of my assumptions were wrong and then I get to fix that and re-evaluate my position. It isn't rare at all to go through several such iterations for a single text and at the end of it I have a much better insight into the material that I thought I already knew well enough to write about.
Don't underestimate the value of these foundational skills.
That's like saying 'speech has no value'. It doesn't have value on its own, but if you can't speak then suddenly there is a whole pile of stuff you can no longer do. The ability to put your thoughts down in writing and to organize them into a hopefully coherent form is an act that has implications far beyond the writing itself. Besides the fact that it can help you to organize your thoughts in the process. Plenty of times when I write a longer piece I find out halfway that one or more of my assumptions were wrong and then I get to fix that and re-evaluate my position. It isn't rare at all to go through several such iterations for a single text and at the end of it I have a much better insight into the material that I thought I already knew well enough to write about.
Don't underestimate the value of these foundational skills.