Re:Code Design Decision – Always throw custom exceptions
by zaphar on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:07PM
(#34057733)
Very few languages actually support Either or Result types ergonomically. I don't have a problem with people using exceptions for these but I do think if the language has compile time type checking it should provide a distinction between checked exceptions and non checked exceptions. I am very much in the minority here but I find it very useful to let robots tell me I forgot something than to discover I forgot it in production. I think this is the useful sort of lazy rather than the not useful sort. Not useful laziness is letting your customers discover the problem.
Re:Code Design Decision – Always throw custom exceptions
by p1necone on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:30PM
(#34058011)
Yeah I agree. I think the problem with checked exceptions in Java is a combination of misuse on both the consuming and the throwing end. They're amazing when they provide a compile time checked way to make sure consumers handle stuff they actually definitely want to handle, but if you add too much noise then all the consuming code is just going to catch and rethrow even the important ones.
Unless you're writing Java where you can force certain exception types to be handled, but people never write that code properly.