News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by masklinn on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:45AM (#34052597)
Hasn't that been pretty well established for a while?

I thought it well grounded that mammals had evolved on Gondwana (the southern part of Pangea) during the process of it splitting away from Laurasia, and had settled Laurasia from Gondwana

Gondwana was composed of now South America, Africa, India, and Australia.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ttyprintk on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:05AM (#34052896)
National Geographic covered it about a year ago:

https://archive.vn/YHs1H

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by WelcomeShorty on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:29AM (#34053183)
Fascinating article.

"Many paleontologists angrily reject the DNA findings, arguing there must be something wrong with the molecular clocks the geneticists use to date their findings. The geneticists counter that paleontologists just haven't found the right fossils yet."

And that should make clear it is not that clear cut as I (with ZERO background knowledge in either area) thought it was.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by brightball on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:53PM (#34055149)
I think there are certain things that we're simply never going to be able to know with certainty, but it sure it fun to talk about.

That Ancient Apocalypse show in Netflix is really interesting along those lines.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:54PM (#34055171)
Hm; I thought that Ancient Apocalypse had been debunked here, as a collection of old myths that had been thoroughly discredited, but now presented as current issues. Just an invented-content money grab kind of thing?
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by rhodorhoades on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:02PM (#34055281)
Well… the whole ‘ancient apocalypse theory’ might be discredited, but the sites they visit date back extremely far into our ancient history. It also shows that pockets of architectural knowledge rapidly advanced and then receded all across the known world. One thing is for sure, the human story is far from a ladder, with periods of around 1000 years of advancements and then everything collapses for a couple generations.

I think it goes back to the OP’s original point… there are some things we cannot ever know for sure but they are fun to learn and talk about.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ummonk on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:38PM (#34057340)
You're making it sound like everything advanced and then receded at the same time across the world. This hasn't been the case since the end of the last glacial period. There have been recedings of local civilizations scattered throughout history, as well as some large scale regional disruptions (e.g. late bronze age collapse, decline of the roman empire), but nothing like periods where everything collapses globally.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by nomel on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:20PM (#34057879)
With "pockets of", I read this

> It also shows that pockets of architectural knowledge rapidly advanced and then receded all across the known world.

as "individual pockets, all around the world, advanced and receded."

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ummonk on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:21PM (#34058582)
Oh, you're right. My objection was based on my own misinterpretation of "pockets" as referring to time periods and/or specific architectural knowledge rather than to particular locations.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by Maursault on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:20PM (#34059818)
> but nothing like periods where everything collapses globally.

What else but a population bottleneck could explain the lack of any genetic diversity to speak of in humans? No human alive today is more distantly related to you than 37th cousin. Any two random individuals are 99.9% identical. That's weird. For this to have occurred, something must have happened everywhere all at once.[1]

[1] https://https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theor...

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by svnt on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:44PM (#34060902)
Not necessarily — it could just as easily have been a founder population event, combined with “weird” sexual selection.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by Maursault on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:00AM (#34067719)
I like this idea. A long time ago, there was one amazingly attractive, irresistibly seductive, incredibly promiscuous and astoundingly prolific breeding individual and sexual athlete: the legendary Don Juan of the late Pleistocene.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ummonk on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:33AM (#34061951)
Yeah I don't disagree, which was why I caveated it by saying "since the end of the last glacial period".

Before that, all bets are off, and I personally do consider the Toba catastrophe a possible explanation for the ridiculously low level of genetic diversity in modern humans outside sub-Saharan Africa.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by usrusr on Monday December 19, 2022 @08:31PM (#34060383)
> It also shows that pockets of architectural knowledge rapidly advanced and then receded all across the known world.

That just means that this level of architectural capability is easily discovered from scratch when circumstances happen to be somewhat right, but then not enough of a gamechanger to endure when when they are not.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by CommitSyn on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:52PM (#34056004)
Graham Hancock says that it hasn't been truly debunked, but that 'establishment archeologists' are programmed to dispute it, or something.

'Establishment archeologists' say it's a bunch of BS.

Mr. Hancock studied sociology for a while before switching gears to journalism.

It's fun to think about, but as far as him being the modern day Galileo, I'm not personally buying it.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by over_bridge on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:53PM (#34057532)
You can always tell a conspiracy theory when it relies on some nebulous group of villains to prop it up. "They don't want you to know what I'm telling you". Tell me clearly who 'they' refers to.

Big archeology? Could we get some names? Maybe an interview with some of them? No, just imagine them like the illuminati but dirtier and poorer, and extremely tribal for some reason.

People just aren't as good at organising as the theories demand they are. They would 100% break ranks if there was a chance to make a major discovery and be famous for it, group loyalty be damned.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by moloch-hai on Monday December 19, 2022 @08:00PM (#34060147)
I have seen exactly what he complains about, many times.

Most recently, the very first reaction was to label him racist. Then he was "dangerous" to The Children.

The fact is, he is wrong in his interpretations, but they are based on evidence. Instead of calling him "dangerous", why not engage with the evidence? The only place I have seen that done is on the "Scientists Against Myths" YT channel, https://youtube.com/@ScientistsAgainstMyths/videos. It is rather off-putting: they forget they are addressing the audience, not the promoters of bad interpretations. You have to endure that to get to the end, each time.

Shows like Graham Hancock's evoke wonder that seems beyond scientists to match. That feeling of wonder is where the next generation of scientists comes from.

It is critically important that scientists say when they don't know something. They should seek out opportunities to mention them, instead of trying to cover them up. Hancock has been right, and historical consensus dead wrong, too many times. He was an early promoter of humans in the Americas before 15kya, and of the comet strike in North America, near the start of the Younger Dryas cold spell, that wiped out mammoths, mastodons, horses, camels, dire wolves, cheetahs, giant beavers, giant sloths, and the Clovis culture; and about megalithic construction dating that far back. There are lessons here on science's ability, and often failure, to self-correct. All of these had evidence "scientists" rejected.

There is plenty of evidence that stone bowls were "turned" to grind them into shape, but the first depictions of it we know of show up thousands of years later. What is the history of "turning"? Somebody might make progress on the question someday, but only if they know there is much unknown.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by over_bridge on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:53PM (#34061342)
The thing that drives me nuts about him and his show can be found in episode 1. He does some scanning of the temple and finds three underground chambers. He cites them as evidence and speculates that they might prove him right and they are a mere 10 meters below him.

And then he leaves.

What?! This is your whole life's work and reputation on the line and you aren't digging 10m to check? It might take a few days but that's nothing. If it's illegal, will he risk nothing for his conviction? He makes the speculation, seeds doubt and then follows through with nothing again and again.

It's the same as those tv psychics. The whole episode we watch as they get closer to a burial site and then right when they are staring out the car window at some woods with dramatic music, the credits roll. Nothing found again!

The first 80% of the episode is fascinating as he shows us these amazing sites. Then inevitably comes the wild speculation disconnected from anything actually shown. Such a frustrating end to every episode. Wake me up when you find something.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by moloch-hai on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:21AM (#34061859)
I didn't try watching it. I would find plenty to object to. But at least he is asking the questions. Nobody else takes us around to all these sites.

I wish someone would take him aside and explain that Earth's rotational precession has nothing to do with solar system orbital dynamics.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by dmix on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:45PM (#34075178)
There's usually some legitimate value in fringes. Even when 95%+ of the fringe can be baseless, total conspiracy tier stuff, but calling 100% of it 'misinformation' and creating a culture of banning/discrediting it out-right and finding weak excuses (ie, accusations racist-by-association because others who are in the fringe happen to be racist, like the current western modus operandi) is dangerous and anti-progress.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by Nursie on Monday December 19, 2022 @11:10PM (#34061437)
> Shows like Graham Hancock's evoke wonder that seems beyond scientists to match.

Because it's not factual? If you aren't constrained by evidence you can evoke whatever wonder you feel like.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by moloch-hai on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:24AM (#34061883)
He tries to stay consistent with the evidence, as he understands it. Speculations are better than suppressing evidence inconsistent with your narrative.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by Nursie on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:17AM (#34062249)
I think that's a pretty serious accusation to make about historians and archaeologists in general, in the context of a discussion of someone who hasn't added to the field, and indeed produces pseudoscientific crap for Netflix.

He may try to stay consistent with the evidence as he understands it in which case it becomes clear he doesn't understand it.

So no, I don't find it inspirational or evocative, any more than I have found talks by psychics, ufologists or homeopaths evocative. They all imagine their beliefs are evidenced...

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by moloch-hai on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:16AM (#34067964)
An accusation richly deserved. Maybe you are unaware of how people were treated when they brought evidence for pre-Clovis Americans? We need not mention Zahi Hawass.

Our expectations for Netflix shows is low. Our expectations for behavior of historians should be higher. Making this be about Hancock would be a mistake.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ChrisMarshallNY on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:02PM (#34055284)
> That Ancient Apocalypse show in Netflix

I started to watch it, then figured out that I didn't really want to.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by mkehrt on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:19PM (#34056349)
Uh, that show is horrific pseudoscience nonsense; you know that, right?
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ummonk on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:34PM (#34056548)
Apparently even on HN some people fall for History Channel type nonsense.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by beaned on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:22PM (#34057141)
Don't understand why you guys characterize these things this way. The person who brought it up would probably just say that it stimulates thought and make you think. In your response, you assume one who shares the show has "fallen for" it - like definitely believes it, without doubt.

Never heard this type of pushback about Ancient Aliens, which is even more ridiculous. I feel like the replies are going to be "but nobody took that seriously anyway." Firstly, I dunno about that. Secondly, not sure anyone's taking Ancient Apocalypse more seriously.

The show presents a theory, it's not claiming a fact. It's so bizarre that out of all the media out there that walks the line between history, science, and outlandish ideas, this one very specific show, for some reason, gets all this hateful focus. Very weird.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ummonk on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:35PM (#34057296)
If someone posted about Ancient Aliens or any other pseudoscience show on here and said it's "really interesting" in a discussion about history (rather than, say, fantasy or entertainment), we'd characterize it the same way. I don't know why you think Ancient Apocalypse is being singled out when I explicitly said "History Channel type nonsense".
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by andrewflnr on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:00PM (#34060616)
> Never heard this type of pushback about Ancient Aliens, which is even more ridiculous.

That's odd, because "this type of pushback" is the only context in which I've heard of "ancient aliens".

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by labster on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:45PM (#34058864)
Ancient Apocalpse is quite entertaining horrific pseudoscience nonsense. You just have to come at it from the right perspective.

For me, it’s fodder for modern TTRPG campaigns and a Sailor Moon prequel fanfic, as well as letting me know of the existence of ancient sites I never knew about.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by brightball on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:32PM (#34060819)
Yep. Doesn’t make it less fun to watch.
Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by ordu on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:29PM (#34056490)
> Ancient Apocalypse show in Netflix is really interesting along those lines.

https://www.sapiens.org/archaeology/ancient-apocalypse-pseud...

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by WalterBright on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:01PM (#34059062)
I watched with some interest. I was amused by their claim that lining up a structure with the sun was some sort of advanced cosmology or evidence that they had advanced science, or any science at all.

The megastructures, while large, showed no evidence of sophisticated engineering.

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by olddustytrail on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:56PM (#34057573)
> Many paleontologists angrily reject

Just this quote immediately put me off the article. Weasel word "many" to start with (how many? Four or five? Half of them?) and followed up with emotive language (how angry were they? Perhaps they were just bored with shoddy justifications?)

Re:Discovery identifies Australia as birthplace of all moder... by Maursault on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:05PM (#34059690)
> Gondwana was composed of now South America, Africa, India, and Australia.

How do we know Gondwana was in the Southern Hemisphere? How do we know that we didn't get the Hemispheres mixed up in the first place?[1]

[1] https://images.theconversation.com/files/162021/original/ima...