I've read a few fan fiction stories that I think were quite good. Protagonist wasn't superhuman, was effectively foiled as seemed appropriate, had flawed notions and perceptions, etc. That being said, I've read many more fanfics that made me cringe. I've enjoyed finding the good ones (that are good to me, anyway).
I'm not going to beat up on fan fiction authors though — I can see the appeal for writing it. In fact I think it is probably a tempting gateway for budding authors.
Just be sure to use a pseudonym.