News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by phpisthebest on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:25PM (#34048033)
Downloading, or possessing copyrighted work that you have not paid for is not actually illegal. It is not drugs, and it is not theft

One of the reasons indivual consumers were targeted for torrents was the fact they were UPLOADING while at the same time downloading

Copyright law is about DISTRIBUTION of a protected work, if I have a copy of a movie, and never distribute it even if the person I obtained it from was not authorized to give me a copy of that money I did no violate copyright law, the person that gave it to me did.

I have yet to see anyone cite the section of copyright law, or any other law that covers the act of DOWNLOADING, only the act of UPLOADING, Sharing, or other wise distributing the work is what violate copyright

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by listenallyall on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:36PM (#34048540)
It is certainly not as clear as you are making it out. Say I purchased a record of Rolling Stones "Sticky Fingers" back in 1977 or whenever. It is a copyrighted work that I paid for, as you stated. Now, can I go into Sam Goody in 1983 and just walk out with a cassette of the same album? In 1994 can I snag a CD off the shelf at Tower Records? Today, can I demand Amazon or Google or Apple provide me with a MP3 copy?

Let's say I bought every single Rolling Stones album, in every format, etc. I own every song they have ever released. Tomorrow they come out with a new box set -- every song in the collection is one that I already own... so now I can possess the box set for free without buying it?

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by UncleEntity on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:36AM (#34049198)
What you can do is copy those onto different media to make a mixed tape to give to your high school girlfriend.

Or back them up on your computer.

Or load them onto your phone.

You’re conflating the physical media with the umm, non-physical media.

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by skelpmargyar on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:39AM (#34049855)
No, you don't possess the box set for free. You already have all the songs in the box set that you paid for, and therefore you already paid for the contents of the box set. You own the box set contents in entirety, just not that specific box set you would walk out with from the store.

If you're confusing the medium with the actual work, consider the following. You own an original painting. Is it illegal to take a picture of that painting and not redistribute it? A picture is not an exact replica of the painting, but someone might say it is a close enough copy. What if you copied the painting by hand on a new canvas to be indistinguishable by human eye from the original. How about if you move the painting from one painting frame to another. Is the painting from considered part of the art? Are any of these illegal if you don't redistribute it? Stealing is illegal. If you take a box set, you're stealing the DVDs not just the contents of the DVDs. If you remux a movie, you didn't pay for that exact version that you now possess. Is that illegal if you don't redistribute it? If you buy a fork, 3D scan it and then 3D print it and eat dinner with it, is it illegal?

It all comes down to laws of one's country. But your analogy doesn't work because you're talking about physically stealing media and we're talking about digital piracy. Some countries it's actually not illegal to download, only upload. It gets even more complicated in the US when it comes to federal and state laws, copyright law, fair use, personal property, etc. I agree that it is not as clear cut legal as he's making it, but it's not as clear cut illegal as I feel you are making it.

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by listenallyall on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:08PM (#34058437)
Doesn't seem to be much dispute that stealing a physical copy is in fact illegal, it's theft. I agree, you agree. Please show me where an exception has been made in any law that says, theft doesn't apply when the goods in question are digital. Digital goods are goods, they have value, they are sold, and they can be stolen/pirated/"borrowed"/whatever words make you feel better.

Do I think the actual likelihood of an individual being prosecuted or sued for downloading torrents is more than 0.000001%? I do not. But getting away with it is not the same as being in the clear.

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by skelpmargyar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:17AM (#34062662)
There isn't an exception that I know of. What I'm saying is if you download a torrent for a movie that you own you can still get a copyright notice. That doesn't really make sense to me.
Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by phpisthebest on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:36AM (#34053279)
>>It's not theft to "possess" Call of Duty if you never paid for it?

From a US law it is not even theft to distribute it, it is infringement of copyright which is not theft.

>Now, can I go into Sam Goody in 1983 and just walk out with a cassette of the same album?

That is shoplifting of a physical product, very very different than replication of digital product

if you were from the future with a Star Trek replicator an when in to Sam Goody, Scanned the Cassette and made a perfect replica of it it would not be theft

Similar if I am a talent artist and I make a perfect replica of a famous Painting to hang on my own wall it would not be a crime, it would only be a crime if I attempted to sell the painting as if it was the original work

See that is the key point, duplication of copyright is not a crime, selling it is, distributing it to others is.

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by listenallyall on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:17PM (#34058545)
> you were from the future with a Star Trek replicator an when in to Sam Goody, Scanned the Cassette and made a perfect replica of it it would not be theft

This is certainly false, no need to speculate. There is presently an entire underground industry of fake Louis Vuitton handbags, and other luxury brands. The goods may be amazing replicas but the legality is clear... an unauthorized source simply cannot produce LV handbags at will, and knowingly purchasing one is not legal either.

Do I think there is any actual risk that an individual person would be prosecuted for buying one of these bags? As I said elsewhere, no. It still doesn't make it legal.

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by phpisthebest on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:02AM (#34061744)
Again the problem here is not the duplicate bag, it is the act of SELLING or DISTRIBUTING the bag

I can take material and make an exact replica of a Louis Vuitton handbag for my own personal use, however if I tried to SELL it as a Louis Vuitton handbag it would be fraud and trademark violation.

So in the case of the Sam Goody, Scanned the Cassette I can take a star Trek replica for my own personal use, perfectly legal. I just could not SELL IT, or DISTRIBUTE IT

>> and knowingly purchasing one is not legal either.

I would love to see the statute on that, not saying your wrong but it would have to be a local law and I bet would not apply to the context of a digital download.

Edit:

Under US Federal law there is no prohibition on Knowingly buying counterfeit goods ( https://www.findlaw.com/consumer/consumer-transactions/buyin... )

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by listenallyall on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:09AM (#34063012)
That links to trafficking statutes. And it states, "it is not a crime under this act for an individual knowingly to purchase goods bearing counterfeit marks, if the purchase is for the individual's personal use." I emphasize under this act, since this act relates to trafficking. That doesn't say that it is not illegal under any other act or law. Customs and Border Patrol seems quite clear: "It is illegal to purchase counterfeit goods." Period. No ifs/ands/buts.

https://www.cbp.gov/trade/fakegoodsrealdangers#:~:text=It%20....

Re:TV Has Always Disappeared. This Feels Different by phpisthebest on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:27AM (#34064437)
CBP provides no code statute under which they have made this declaration so it seems to be more of a scare tactic than at legal opinion. Further given the context to CBP they are also most likely talking about knowingly importing counterfeit products into the US after buying while traveling

That is way way off course from the topic of digital nor does it make it illegal to buy just illegal to import

You have yet to provide the needed statute citation to back your claims that it is either illegal to buy a counterfeit nor how that would apply to the original thesis that it is note illegal to download a copyrighted work only illegal to distribute or upload it