Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance
by pilom on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:00PM
(#3404255)
You read the graph wrong. Finland, Australia, Korea, Japan and New Zealand get better results for the same amount of pay. The farther above the line in their graph, the better the relative performance of the teachers given their income and vise versa, the countries below the graph have worse results given their income.
Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance
by TomOfTTB on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:06PM
(#3404283)
I think I phrased it badly but the point still stands. The authors point was that teachers pay is the deciding factor in results. My point was those countries pay the same Denmark and the UK yet are getting better results. So pay is not the deciding factor.
Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance
by wwweston on Thursday December 29, 2011 @11:57AM
(#3404243)
"If you look at Finland... paying their teachers well and who aren't getting results."
I'd been given to understand Finland is generally regarded as one of the better education systems in the world.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8601207.stm http://siteselection.com/ssinsider/snapshot/sf011210.htm http://schoolmatters.knoxnews.com/forum/topics/how-does-finl...
Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance
by TomOfTTB on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:02PM
(#3404268)
You could very well be right. My point was the authors' conclusion didn't match their underlying data. So the validity of their underlying data didn't come into play.
Re:Paying teachers more results in higher pupil performance
by anamax on Thursday December 29, 2011 @01:06PM
(#3404557)
> I'd been given to understand Finland is generally regarded as one of the better education systems in the world.
Of course Finland (and most Northern European countries) has another advantage - they're teaching Finns.
Pretty much anything you do in those monocultures "works". So, their success with any program tells us nothing about how the same program will work in a cultures where things do fail, let alone diverse environments.
Plus we have anecdotal evidence that contradicts their conclusion in the U.S: Individual State salaries vary pretty significantly ($37,000 to $59,000) yet education results don't seem to reflect those salaries
Teacher Salary By State: http://www.teacherportal.com/teacher-salaries-by-state
State Education Rankings: http://www.vermontbiz.com/news/september/state-education-ran...
I don't entirely disagree with the thesis that making "teacher" a more revered position will draw better people to it. But there are clearly other factors at play that the authors chose to disregard because they wanted to prove their already established conclusion.
(If it were me I'd be comparing Switzerland, Germany and Sweden and trying to figure what the differences are there)