Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by weinzierl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:15AM
(#34037812)
Just a few says ago there was a thread where artists recreated Disney art with A.I. I simply cannot imagine a world, where this stance will stand. Sooner or later we will see a massive crackdown by the large copyright holders.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by bbig on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:35AM
(#34038017)
Curious how such a crackdown would even be enforced. Stable Diffusion is allowing artists to opt-out, so I guess that's a start?
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:43AM
(#34038132)
The whole idea that the copyright holder needs to opt-out is seriously broken. Copyright is not 'opt-out'. Stable diffusion has set themselves up for trouble, this should have been opt-in.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by jl6 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:24AM
(#34037920)
A key litmus test: can an AI produce output that can substitute for a copyrighted work, to the extent that the commercial value of that copyrighted work is diminished? e.g. if a future hypothetical DALL-E-for-video can diffuse a mkv file containing something that plays very much like Star Wars, then surely possessing the model would be treated as possessing a copy of the movie.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by awb on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:19AM
(#34037871)
What if a marketing team generates 100 candidate characters with AI for the next feature film, selects the best one and then writes an incredibly detailed brief for a human artist to reverse engineer the character. Could you then copyright the human generated art?