Re:Mathematician withdraws preprint 24 years after initial s...
by andrewflnr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:59PM
(#34035181)
A decade is far too short a time span for a shift like that. I'm aware that journals are quite entrenched; I've heard the phrase "publish or perish". If it happens, it'll be on more of a generational time scale. It has to be proven possible for someone to make a career without getting "published". Maybe by the time we're both almost dead, truth will be enough. :)
And yeah, all those features you mention that academia values are useful for the press, too. It's really handy to have a finite set of vetted sources, rather than trying to keep track of the reputations of various scientists and use that to parse their comment threads. That's why I said it will be rough.
So-called "high-impact" journals perform a gatekeeping, credentialing, and attention-focusing function that is valued by the institutions of academia. What you and most people on HN probably see as a bug is a feature to them. It is part of why I left, to be honest.