Re:Mathematician withdraws preprint 24 years after initial s...
by lupire on Saturday December 17, 2022 @08:36PM
(#34034208)
What do you see as non-neutral?
Re:Mathematician withdraws preprint 24 years after initial s...
by abnry on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:00PM
(#34034338)
It seems curated towards scientific misdeeds. Maybe non-neutral is the wrong word, but I could totally understand being upset having your name on the site.
Re:Mathematician withdraws preprint 24 years after initial s...
by matthewdgreen on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:25PM
(#34034484)
People won’t feel comfortable retracting papers with errors if the practice in the industry is to highlight the retraction on a giant billboard next to items like “Scientist commits massive fraud.” If that’s the consequence for honestly correcting your own scientific record, better just to leave incorrect work out there.
Re:Mathematician withdraws preprint 24 years after initial s...
by Brian_K_White on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:30PM
(#34042873)
For one thing, why is everything written as "scientist retracts paper" instead of "paper retracted" ?
From their homepage:
>The week at Retraction Watch featured:
> Mathematician withdraws preprint – 24 years after initial submission
> Penn says access to former Twitter employee’s thesis was ‘mistakenly closed off’ following Elon Musk tweets
> PLOS flags nearly 50 papers by controversial French COVID researcher for ethics concerns
> Cancer researcher banned from federal funding for faking data in nearly 400 images in 16 grant applications
> ‘I never asked or expected to be included as an author’: Retired Penn State prof has three retractions for manipulated peer review
The thing about mathematics papers is that, for the most part, social acceptance is _the_ test of research. I say social acceptance, because that is what it is, namely a culture of rigorous logical review of the arguments in a paper. As such, you don't really have ethics concerns relating to faked data or p-hacking in a math paper.
When a math paper is retracted, it is almost certainly due to an honest mistake. Papers with such an error are likely not a very significant paper to begin with--as the error likely escaped noticed because there were fewer eyes on it--or there is a very deep and subtle error that would be hard for anyone to catch.