Yes and no. Tracking airplanes is something hobbyists have been doing for decades; there are people who hang out by airports and record every flight in and out. The PIA program can be useful for realtime masking but the information is far from secret — nor should it be, imo.
> "Elon Musk, for example, has a Gulfstream and there's only so many people that fly that particular plane out of Brownsville, Texas and fly to the same airports," Sweeney told Insider.
> ...
> "These privacy mitigation programs are effective for real-time operations but do not guarantee absolute privacy," an FAA spokesperson said. "A flight can still be tracked in other ways such as a Freedom of Information Act request, www.LiveATC.com, ADSB Exchange, or a frequently departed airport."
https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-appears-use-faa-to...
> According to the United States Department of Justice (DOJ), the legal definition of "stalking" means "engaging in a course of conduct directed at a specific person that would cause a reasonable person to fear for his or her safety or the safety of others or suffer substantial emotional distress."
http://www.oxfordlegal.com/legal-definition-stalking/
Using an antenna to figure out somebody's approximate location and publicizing it, when that somebody already has stalkers going after his children [1], seems like it would cause reasonable fear
[1]: https://nypost.com/2022/12/15/elon-musk-shares-video-of-craz...
https://nitter.it/pic/orig/enc/bWVkaWEvRmtBR0FsUGFjQUE4MjQzL...
https://nitter.it/@ZacksJerryRig/status/1603286484785586178
Moreover, the narrative he's presenting doesn't make sense. Not only did the @ElonJet account not tweet for over 24 hours prior to the alleged incident, but people have determined that the location doesn't make sense for what he's claiming.
Details on this?
Don't worry they want to classify that as cyber stalking next.
So PIA in a nutshell means that you can request a private identifier for your plane, that is not publicly linkable to you.
And if the identifier is compromised, you can request a new one.
Which would make the identifier itself, and its real-time location, public information, but the knowledge of who owns the identifier would remain as private information.