Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists?
by nonbirithm on Thursday December 15, 2022 @02:25PM
(#34004356)
> Instead of replacing crappy jobs and freeing up peoples time to enjoy their life, we’re actually automating enjoyable pursuits.
In my case, I don't happen to find drawing or painting enjoyable. I think this is what makes me and many other people a prime target for addiction to AI-generated art, since as a programmer I can tweak the experience using my skills.
So without any sort of generation, how does one solve the problem of not wanting to draw, but still wanting a visual product to enjoy? Probably virtuosity and integrity, a willingness to move past mistakes, and a positive mindset. The sorts of things that have little to do with the specific mechanics of writing code in an IDE to provoke a dopamine response. I sometimes feel I lack some of those kinds of qualities, and yet I can somehow still generate interesting results with Stable Diffusion.
I will relish the day when an AI is capable of convincing me that drawing with my own two hands is more interesting than using its own ability to generate a finished piece in seconds.
So I agree that, on a bigger scale beyond the improvement of automated art, this line of thinking will do more harm than good. An AI can take the fall for people who can't or don't want to fight the difficult battles needed to grow into better people, and that in turn validates that kind of mindset. It gives even the people who detest the artistic process a way to have the end result.
I think this is part of the reason why the anti-AI-art movement has pushed back so loudly. AI art teaches us the wrong lessons of what it means to be human. People could become trained to not want to go outside and walk amongst the trees and experience the world if an AI can hallucinate a convincing replacement from the comfort of someone's room.
In my case, I don't happen to find drawing or painting enjoyable. I think this is what makes me and many other people a prime target for addiction to AI-generated art, since as a programmer I can tweak the experience using my skills.
So without any sort of generation, how does one solve the problem of not wanting to draw, but still wanting a visual product to enjoy? Probably virtuosity and integrity, a willingness to move past mistakes, and a positive mindset. The sorts of things that have little to do with the specific mechanics of writing code in an IDE to provoke a dopamine response. I sometimes feel I lack some of those kinds of qualities, and yet I can somehow still generate interesting results with Stable Diffusion.
I will relish the day when an AI is capable of convincing me that drawing with my own two hands is more interesting than using its own ability to generate a finished piece in seconds.
So I agree that, on a bigger scale beyond the improvement of automated art, this line of thinking will do more harm than good. An AI can take the fall for people who can't or don't want to fight the difficult battles needed to grow into better people, and that in turn validates that kind of mindset. It gives even the people who detest the artistic process a way to have the end result.
I think this is part of the reason why the anti-AI-art movement has pushed back so loudly. AI art teaches us the wrong lessons of what it means to be human. People could become trained to not want to go outside and walk amongst the trees and experience the world if an AI can hallucinate a convincing replacement from the comfort of someone's room.