News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by residualmind on Thursday December 15, 2022 @07:47AM (#33998702)
I would argue if people are allowed to see your art for free, so should AI models.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by dotancohen on Thursday December 15, 2022 @08:32AM (#33999233)
Bad argument. Being allowed to see art and being allowed to copy art are two different things. Being allowed to _copy_ is a reserved _right_, that's the root of the word copyright.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by concordDance on Thursday December 15, 2022 @08:48AM (#33999395)
Except they aren't copying it, but instead drawing inspiration from it. Which all humans have done forever.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by AlexandrB on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:38AM (#34000132)
This falls apart for 2 reasons. First, I don't think there's any technical definition of "inspiration" that applies to a deeply nested model of numerical weights. It's a machine. A hammer does not draw inspiration from nails that have been hammered in before. Second an AI is not a human under the law and there's no reason to think that an activity that would be considered "transformative" (e.g. learning then painting something similar) when done by a human would still be considered such if performed by an AI.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by mejutoco on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:53AM (#34000397)
Following your logic: if AI is like humans why don't we tax its work?
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by CuriouslyC on Thursday December 15, 2022 @10:51AM (#34001379)
If an AI ever gets paid for the work it does, I'm sure we will.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by CuriouslyC on Thursday December 15, 2022 @10:53AM (#34001418)
Bad argument. Copying art is not the crime, distributing the copied art is the crime. The Disney Gestapo can't send storm troopers to your house if your kid draws a perfect rendition of Mickey, but they can if your kid draws a bunch of perfect renditions and sells them online.
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by peoplefromibiza on Thursday December 15, 2022 @08:13AM (#33998993)
people are allowed to take a walk in the park, so why cars or tanks or bulldozers are not?
Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by residualmind on Thursday December 15, 2022 @08:24AM (#33999142)
A bulldozer destroys the park and other people's ability to enjoy it -- active, destructive. Passively training a model on an artwork does not change the art in the slightest -- passive, non-destructive

Mind you, this is not talking about the usage rights of images generated from such a model, that's a completely different story and a legal one.

Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by 6P58r3MXJSLi on Thursday December 15, 2022 @08:36AM (#33999281)
> A bulldozer destroys the park and other people's ability to enjoy it

hear hear...

> Passively training a model on an artwork does not change the art in the slightest

copyright holders, I mean individual authors, people who actually produced the content being used, disagree.

They say AI is like a bulldozer destroying the park to them.

Which technically is true, it's a machine that someone (some interested party maybe?) is trying to disguise as a human, doing human stuff.

But it's not.

> passive, non-destructive

Passive, non-destructive, in this context means

- passive: people send the images to you, you don't go looking for them

- non-destructive: people authorized you, otherwise it's destructive of their rights.

Re:Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists? by bakugo on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:39AM (#34000140)
AI models are not people.