As a contractor I waive the rights to the code I write and any associated documentation BUT it's explicitly stated in my contract that I am entitled to use the general, technical know-how I acquired during the project how I wish.
The spirit is that it's unreasonable to expect from me to pretend I don't know how to approach problems I've been solving all this time.
Really it's a mess, because of course you are going to take your experience and knowledge with you. Bottom line, those employees are finally free of ASML after the legal settlement with the XTAL lawsuit, and have no contract with them that they can be accused of violating, and so they can go work for whomever they want. If the new employer violates an ASML patent, then ASML can go after the employer like anyone else. But who these employees work for isn't ASML's concern anymore.
> employee of the American company who continued to use IP
> that was sold to ASML.
In the except above, you've described the means by which the company stole the IP and is using the IP illegally. How can you possibly believe that the company didn't steal IP after writing this? Did you forget a word/sentence/paragraph that explains this obvious contradiction?
So do you really believe this or is this just an anti-China thing? Fun Fact: Many innovators in Silicon valley did the exact same thing, discovering something at one company, and then taking it to another where it was more fully developed. They then went on to continue to innovate completely new things. And sometimes there were lawsuits flying around about who stole which IP, yet the same workers continued to be hired by tech companies, and people didn't automatically assume that anyone who hired them subsequently was participating in IP theft.
I guarantee you that former Uber self-driving engineers are still gainfully employed, many in the field of self-driving cars, and no one is accusing their new employers of trying to steal IP from Google.
How do you justify applying this double standard?
Is it not obvious what the line is here? Don't give IP that isn't yours to companies that hire you. It doesn't matter if its from your memory or files that you copied and physically moved with you. This individual did not follow this obvious rule. If you can't do your job without stealing IP, then your job is criminal.
> However there is no evidence that the Chinese company stole any IP from ASML
You referenced the chinese company hiring the person with the sentence
> In the except above, you've described the means by which the company stole the IP and is using the IP illegally. How can you possibly believe that the company didn't steal IP after writing this?
This seems to me that you propose the person being hired by a company is proof enough of the chinese company actually using this technology.
(The company accused and fined for IP violation was an american company employing the person in question.)
However there is no evidence that the Chinese company stole any IP from ASML, and certainly there has been no court case or finding of fact suggesting that the Chinese company is using the stolen IP. The offense committed by the Chinese company is hiring the employee of the American company who continued to use IP that was sold to ASML.