News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LosslessCut: lossless video/audio editing by seba_dos1 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @10:43AM (#33970303)
That's not "a problem with ffmpeg-based editors"; that's the only way to do it lossless.

Some containers such as Matroska are able to store an offset (and ffmpeg does that), so it starts playing from exact wanted position even though the actual stream contains data since the last keyframe. Some players ignore that though.

Re:LosslessCut: lossless video/audio editing by formerly_proven on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @11:03AM (#33970661)
Depending on the encoder the GOP size / keyframe interval can be more or less unbounded as well. Typically you'd only have a few seconds per, but for example CCTV cameras are happy to produce minute-long GOPs. Seeking backwards in a video player tends to not work so well at that point, and most NLEs are significantly unhappy with such a file.
Re:LosslessCut: lossless video/audio editing by _flux on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @11:10AM (#33970760)
I wonder though if this could be solved with edit lists, supported e.g. by ISO BMFF. Not all players support them completely, though, for example I believe mpv only supports one edit, so I guess that's not useful for general purpose use..