Step 1: Alice uploads some media to Bob's website
Step 2: Charlie decides Alice's upload violates his copyright
Step 3: Charlie sends Bob a DMCA takedown notice.
Step 4: Bob takes down Alice's media, issues Alice a notice that he's received a claim, and is now protected from being sued by Charlie.
Step 5: Alice disagrees that her upload violates Charlie's copyright, and issues a counter-claim to Bob.
Step 6: Bob reinstates Alice's upload, notifies Charlie that Alice has contested his claim, and is now protected from being sued by Alice.
Step 7: Charlie sues Alice, because he still believes the content to be in violation of his copyright, or gives up
Step 8: Court case / counter suit decides damages between Charlie and Alice
The problem is not the DMCA system, which if anything is too generous to the media host. The problem is YouTube's added bullshit layer, which goes something like "Charlie hints that he might send a DMCA takedown, Bob takes down Alice's video and threatens to ban her from the platform"
Given how many popular videos sit on the edge of copyright abuse it’s not really in Google’s interest to do this anyway.