News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A list of advanced math tricks by Terence Tao by dj_mc_merlin on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:08PM (#33957172)
You're right there. Or at least you definitely have a point.

I would question whether being able to see this pinhole perspective of the maths he's talking about really means I "understand" it, or if that's just a semantic game. I don't feel like I am any more able to do something with the information than a second ago, even though I "understand" it more.

Re:A list of advanced math tricks by Terence Tao by AlexSW on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:58PM (#33957832)
Glad it made a bit of sense! But that's a fair point about whether it really constitutes 'understanding'.

I suppose it's equivalent here to whether knowing the meaning of a particular sentence in the alien language qualifies as understanding it, vs being able to meaningfully speak about it in this alien language, and use the sentence in a conversation. Seems like just semantics to me.