News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by prepend on Monday December 12, 2022 @08:57AM (#33954637)
Isn’t it telling that this work wasn’t done by the “big four?”

Given that the Big Four like money and are ostensibly the biggest and oldest and with the best reputation. Any perceived shaky but actually strong firm would come out gangbusters with “Old Accounting firm stakes its reputation that we aren’t full of shit.”

After the death/execution/seppuku of Anderson after Enron, the remaining four seem extra conservative these days so they would likely only take on a job if it was reputable. Even if it means hundreds of millions of dollars in fees.

This is an example where old fuddy duddy finance should help me as a consumer.

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by kasey_junk on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:13AM (#33954773)
Mazars isn’t a fly by night operation. They are old and big, just not in the big 4.

Traditional finance views Mazars audits (which this isn’t) the same as a big 4 audit.

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by prepend on Monday December 12, 2022 @07:44PM (#33962922)
I’m aware of Mazars and their position. I didn’t say they are fly by night, I said they aren’t as reputable or established as the big 4.

My point stands that if you want to assuage doubts, you don’t hire the #11 [0] (or #21 if just looking at US revenue [1]) firm to do it. This would be simple to get PWC or someone. But a firm that big isn’t willing to touch this kind of operation.

[0] https://big4accountingfirms.org/the-top-accounting-firms-in-... [1] https://www.accountingtoday.com/the-2021-top-100-firms-data

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by poutrathor on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:12AM (#33954764)
Mazars is 5th in Europe, 24 400 employees and it makes ~2 bilions in turnover.

this above comment is not bringing much value to the discussion I think.

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by prepend on Monday December 12, 2022 @07:57PM (#33963065)
They aren’t top 10 globally or even in the US.

They aren’t a tiny firm, but they aren’t even in the same league as the big companies. Mazars has $2B in revenue and the smallest of the big4, KPMG, has $32B.

They aren’t competitors and Mazars doesn’t even compete for work.

Here’s a list of all major US banks and their auditors [0]. Mazars doesn’t audit a single one and 90% are big4.

In my comment, I wanted to point out that Binance is not doing what a reputable financial firm would do, hire a major accounting firm and have them audit. Hiring a regional firm means they likely went down the list until they finally found an auditor willing to make any statement.

It looks silly to anyone who understands auditing.

My point was also that major audit firms risk dissolution if they are convicted like Anderson was. So there’s no way that a firm is going to risk their $30B+ audit book in exchange for a few million in fees.

Mazars doesn’t have as big a book to risk. And their customers aren’t major exchange listed firms that would have to fire them if they were convicted of fraud.

[0] https://ibanknet.com/scripts/callreports/filist.aspx?type=au...

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:30PM (#33963931)
KPMG does more advisory and tax than audit; Mazars the other way around. Still much bigger, but it's not apples/apples. Mazars clients are mostly European; they're BNP Paribas' auditor.
Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by YawningAngel on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:45AM (#33955122)
I think it's a very reasonable observation. An audit from PWC is materially different to an audit from a local accounting firm with less of a reputation at stake. The parent happens to be in error about which category Mazar's falls into (since they're probably the largest accounting firm outside the big four), but people are going to make reasonable but ignorant comments sometimes. I myself thought the exact same thing and only didn't say it because I happened to google Mazars out of curiosity.
Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by AdamN on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:31AM (#33954972)
Ever since the Trump stuff, I don't think Mazar's gets alot of trust anymore:

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/14/nyregion/mazars-trump-org...

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by poutrathor on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:19AM (#33955526)
Fair point but I am pretty sure so many accounting firms messed up quite often. Without slowing their business much.

I remember this one for example that was probably missed by most people. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-58671915

Trump was a loaded client and any firm doing business with any politicians should be extra-careful

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by AdamN on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @06:59AM (#33982364)
These scandals can have an impact on the business, but it's true that it's not always that bad and companies can continue to be bad actors:

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/30/world/africa/mckinsey-cor... https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/anderseneffect.asp

Re:Binance is trying to calm investors, but its finances rem... by patentatt on Monday December 12, 2022 @09:11AM (#33954753)
Also, same firm that Trump worked with. I see a potential pattern here.