News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by account-5 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @02:30AM (#33941036)
Am I right in thinking no one has been able to detect dark matter despite decades of attempts and research?

My understanding is that based on observations of what can be seen galaxies move as if there's move stuff in them??

If you hypothesis that this extra stuff is dark matter but can't detect it, how do you know it's real?

How have you ruled out all the normal stuff that doesn't give off light or stuff we can't see at the distances we're looking over? Like planets, rocks, dust, etc. Couldn't that stuff, which to my mind there would be vastly more of than stars, make up the extra gravity?

I'm aware I might be talking complete shit because I'm completely ignorant of the detail here. I would love an understandable explanation as to why that's wrong.

Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by negativelambda on Sunday December 11, 2022 @02:50AM (#33941135)
> Am I right in thinking no one has been able to detect dark matter despite decades of attempts and research?

Yup [1]

> My understanding is that based on observations of what can be seen galaxies move as if there's move stuff in them??

Yup [2]

> If you hypothesis that this extra stuff is dark matter but can't detect it, how do you know it's real?

It produces certain effects in various different enviromennts or domains, which lends more support to that hypothesis. By certain different domains, I mean like Galaxy and cluster dynamics, gravitational lensing around galaxies and clusters and the precise fluctuations seen in the cosmic microwave background, these are all very different regimes but all seem to support the hypothesis of extra mass which is not interacting electromagnetically.

> How have you ruled out all the normal stuff that doesn't give off light or stuff we can't see at the distances we're looking over?

There are research efforts to look for exactly this kind of stuff; Massive compact halo object (MACHOS). However they don't see enough of it to account for the observations we see in galaxies and galaxy clusters. [3]

[1] https://lss.fnal.gov/archive/2022/conf/fermilab-conf-22-180-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter#Observational_evid... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_compact_halo_object#De...

Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by lkrubner on Sunday December 11, 2022 @04:00AM (#33941477)
Sort of, but gravitational lensing has been seen in places where there is no visible matter. If dark matter doesn't exist, then you'd have to come up with another explanation for the gravitation lensing:

https://kipac.stanford.edu/highlights/using-gravitational-le...

Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by Beldin on Sunday December 11, 2022 @05:08AM (#33941847)
You're absolutely right and this is the one thing about dark mayer that doesn't sound like "just keep sprinkling it on your problem till it works."

I don't know enough about the found examples of gravitational lensing to know whether all possible arrangements of black holes that could have the same effect, have been considered and found lacking. But I presume so.

Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by dbdoskey on Sunday December 11, 2022 @06:24AM (#33942270)
Re:Is dark matter’s “nightmare scenario” true? by exmadscientist on Sunday December 11, 2022 @02:50AM (#33941137)
I hate to be that guy, but many of those points are exactly the subject of this article.