News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:32AM (#33932913)
Setting aside the almost impossible feat that every business could collude to arbitrarily double their profit margins, even if your assumption is granted, it would ultimately have no effect on consumers as a whole.

So, assuming businesses are more profitable, they ultimately have 2 things they could do with that extra profit:

1. Hoard it and do nothing with it

2. Invest it

In the case of 1, doing this is tantamount to taking money out of circulation (i.e. lowering supply). When the supply is lowered then everyone else’s purchasing power increases which is a benefit to them.

In the case of 2, investing it, either by starting new businesses or loaning it, means that they are effectively redistributing that money to others in the form of wages. Which is beneficial to workers who also happen to be consumers.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by vineyardmike on Saturday December 10, 2022 @07:23PM (#33938573)
> Setting aside the almost impossible feat that every business could collude to arbitrarily double their profit margins,

1. It doesn’t have to be collusion. They could even raise margins ahead of expected downturns to prep for savings. There could even be a global pandemic that reduces supply, leading businesses to raise prices in relation to demand and shortages, but those same companies not reducing prices when supply increased.

2. The article actually states that many businesses have recorded record profits recently while costs stayed the same. It’s literally happening in front of us, don’t deny it is a possibility while witnessing it as a reality.

> In the case of 2, investing it, either by starting new businesses or loaning it, means that they are effectively redistributing that money to others in the form of wages.

Why does that have to go to wages? They could distribute it to executives and shareholders as dividends or stock buybacks, or use it to invest into many schemes like private equity that don’t help average people eg. buying twitter and layoff half the employees… which is the opposite of increasing distribution.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:12PM (#33939999)
> It doesn’t have to be collision

It does have to be collusion, otherwise competition to keep prices low

> don’t deny it is a possibility while witnessing it as a reality

I’m not denying that profit margins (of some companies) are higher. I’m claiming that it is not to the detriment of the consumer at large. Also for every company that is seeing increased profits, there’s another one that is seeing a decrease

> Why does it have to go to wages?

It has to go somewhere, right? Even if it goes to “shareholders” or “executives”, or “private equity”, either they are hoarding it (increasing everyone elses purchasing power) or they are investing it (spending it on someone elses wages).

The act of buying Twitter just transfers money from one person to a group of other people (shareholders) who are then free to do what they want with their newfound liquidity. Again, if they hoard that money, then it increases purchasing power for everyone else, and if they invest/save it, then it goes to paying peoples wages

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by vineyardmike on Sunday December 11, 2022 @04:27PM (#33947730)
> It does have to be collusion, otherwise competition to keep prices low

Competition works half as well as people think it does. It’s long shown that companies will see collective price rises for products even in the absence of direct collusion. Most products don’t trend to being sold at-cost, which is what you’d expect in this case. Why do any products have any product margin? Isn’t every product margin an opportunity for competition?

> I’m claiming that it is not to the detriment of the consumer at large.

I don’t know. I personally haven’t noticed inflation much but we’re talking about it an awful lot for nobody to be affected. The people affected the most are the people who can least afford it.

> Even if it goes to “shareholders” or “executives”, or “private equity”, either they are hoarding it (increasing everyone elses purchasing power) or they are investing it (spending it on someone elses wages).

Trickle down isn’t real. Lots of money gets spent in ways that doesn’t effectively help wages. Money does get hoarded, but it’s not enough to be meaningfully helpful at purchasing power.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:29PM (#33990011)
> Isn’t every product margin an opportunity for competition?

Yes. Which is why marginal revenue does trend towards marginal cost, contrary to what you’re claiming. High margins are a signal to the market that more supply is needed

> Trickle down isn’t real.

Trickle down is a misnomer. It’s actually more like trickle up as all it means is that people who make the money get to decide how to spend it vs. having a centralized, top-down organization (the government) decide how to spend it

> Money does get hoarded, but it’s not enough to be meaningfully helpful at purchasing power.

If hoarded money is not enough to meaningfully help purchasing power then the other side of that coin is that the increased profits of these companies is necessarily not enough to meaningfully effect purchasing power in a negative way. In both cases, it’s the same amount of money, just on different sides of the ledger

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by ydlr on Saturday December 10, 2022 @10:56AM (#33933650)
All of this is true is a company rises prices without affecting the behavior of others.

When suppliers notice their customers raising prices, they raise prices to capture some of that increase. Likewise, workers will try to increase wages.

The result is a profit-price spiral that gets misdiagnosed as wage-price spiral.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:20PM (#33940032)
I’ll grant this, but no matter what it’s called, ultimately no group (consumer vs. business) is better or worse off. In such a spiral it’s just the nominal numbers that are changing and not the ‘real’ numbers

What keeps this from happening, I think, is the presence of competition which would stop both cohorts, workers and businesses, from increasing their prices indefinitely

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by ydlr on Monday December 12, 2022 @08:38AM (#33954480)
> I’ll grant this, but no matter what it’s called, ultimately no group (consumer vs. business) is better or worse off. In such a spiral it’s just the nominal numbers that are changing and not the ‘real’ numbers

In the long-term, yes. In the moment, the experience of rapidly rising prices really sucks. It doesn't occur smoothly or evenly.

> What keeps this from happening, I think, is the presence of competition which would stop both cohorts, workers and businesses, from increasing their prices indefinitely

You are absolutely right. And inadequate competition in many sectors is definitely a contributor to current inflation.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by vineyardmike on Sunday December 11, 2022 @03:13AM (#33941259)
> ultimately no group is better or worse off. In such a spiral it’s just the nominal numbers that are changing and not the ‘real’ numbers

Except that wages tend to change less fluidly than prices so there’s usually a lag resulting in less purchasing power for consumers.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:19PM (#33989810)
Yes that is true, but under the assumption that prices are only raising due to corporations increasing them, then my original post comes into play where for everyone that is worse off, there is someone necessarily better off. Thus the consumer as a whole is unaffected. Because again, if that money is hoarded then that means the hoarder is consuming less and thus supplies are increased for everyone else. Or they are investing and just spending that money into the hands of a different group
Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by klyrs on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:56AM (#33934170)
Don't assume that this would happen overnight. Real wages have been essentially flat for median workers since the early 70s, while CEOs have greatly increased their own real salaries and companies have made a greater focus on short term profits and dividends for their stockholders. The common justification I see for 100:1 CEO to median income gaps is that "CEOs provide value to the shareholders." They do that specifically by depressing the wages of their employees to make room for dividends.

And it's not like any of the above is some shadowy conspiracy. It's the mainstream practice that is literally taught in business schools worldwide and championed by politicians, most famously by Regan and Thatcher. You're paraphrasing the "trickle down" theory yourself.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:35PM (#33940122)
> Real wages have been flat for median workers since the 70s

Real wages for workers in what context? The US? The industrialized nations? Perhaps the better explanation for this (assuming it’s true) is that the median worker in industrialized nations has had productivity that has grown at a slower rate than the median worker in developing markets.

Would be interesting to see what the worldwide statistics are for CEO to worker pay.

> They do that specifically by depressing the wages of their employees to make room for dividends.

Can’t “workers” also be shareholders? If not in their own companies, then at least in any publicly traded company. The world isn’t cleanly divided into “worker” and “owner”. People can be both. And again, those dividends have to go somewhere. My original post applies here, where it either gets hoarded or invested, and no matter which one happens, it is beneficial to the consumer at large.

I’d consider “trickle down” to be quite the misnomer. I think “trickle up” is more apt because in the end, all it means is that the people who make the money in the first place, get to decide what they do with it as opposed to being taxed and sending their money off to a centralized (often divided and inefficient) govt to decided what to do with it.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by vineyardmike on Sunday December 11, 2022 @04:30PM (#33947758)
> Can’t “workers” also be shareholders? If not in their own companies, then at least in any publicly traded company. The world isn’t cleanly divided into “worker” and “owner”. People can be both.

Yea but most people aren’t. Lower-income people barely have retirement accounts with index funds in it. The people that are “owners” in a meaningful sense are not workers.

Re:Labor costs point to corporate profit as main inflation d... by finspeech on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#33989692)
Yeah, but there are plenty of people who do own assets. It’s not just the 1% that owns all the assets.

Plus, the market, and peoples’ places in it are not static. Many lower income people are lower income due to the fact that they are young and don’t have the knowledge/experience of their older peers. They don’t stay that way. They are able to earn more and save/invest more as they level up their skills