News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by beagle3 on Monday December 26, 2011 @09:12AM (#3392924)
> If they don't want customers (one, few or many), they shouldn't start a business.

Legally, there is no such a thing as a "business". A corporation or LLP exists to limit liability. That's it. "Business" is not well defined in the real world.

Is an HFT proprietary trading firm, trading its own money on an anonymous exchange, with no customers or clients, not a business?

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by nknight on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:34PM (#3393869)
> Legally, there is no such a thing as a "business".

The US Internal Revenue Service would probably disagree with you there. If I didn't file Schedule C ("Profit or Loss From Business") every year, I'd be in prison.

> Is an HFT proprietary trading firm, trading its own money on an anonymous exchange, with no customers or clients, not a business?

An HFT with no "customers" is simply an agent of its owners. The only sense in which you could call it a business is that it happens to have the form of an incorporated entity, which many businesses also happen to have the form of. A is part of B, C is part of B, does that mean all As are Cs?

You've latched on to one of the bizarre artifacts of the modern American legal system, not a fundamental principle of business.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by beagle3 on Monday December 26, 2011 @04:45PM (#3394014)
> If I didn't file Schedule C ("Profit or Loss From Business") every year, I'd be in prison.

I wasn't aware of that; In that case, there is at least one legal definition of business with a lot of merit behind it (gun wielding people will put you in prison if you fall under it but do not file schedule C). And whatever the IRS regulations for Schedule C define as a business, is a business.

> An HFT with no "customers" is simply an agent of its owners.

Aren't all businesses? Isn't the defining property of business is doing transactions? (of whatever kind). Can you summarize what the requirement for Schedule C filing is?

> You've latched on to one of the bizarre artifacts of the modern American legal system, not a fundamental principle of business.

Where are the fundamental principles detailed? I agree the vast majority of businesses have customers, but I don't think it's a defining property -- there are a lot of people with customers who do not consider themselves having a "business" (Although the IRS might think otherwise)

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by Shorel on Monday December 26, 2011 @10:17AM (#3393052)
So you say that the real world is mostly made from legal definitions?

I would wonder what that would mean for string theory.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by beagle3 on Monday December 26, 2011 @12:37PM (#3393362)
> So you say that the real world is mostly made from legal definitions?

No. I'm saying that arguing about what a "business" is or isn't is futile, because something which is a business to one is not a business to the other. Had there been a legal definition, there would have been merit to such a discussion.

> I would wonder what that would mean for string theory.

I wonder too. So far, string theory has not been predictive, and as such is a very interesting intellectual experiment, but not a lot more. When it can actually predict something testable that disagrees with another theory, we'll be able to call it "science".