News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG: What's your current take on reddit's comment system? by acgourley on Thursday July 12, 2007 @07:18PM (#33929)
I have the same problem with reddit and digg: I like to read exceptionally downmodded comments. When comments get modded down so much that they are not displayed, and also they generate a lot of responses, it's the kind of thing I can help but look at. Like a train wreck I suppose.

It actually sucks me into the troll MORE when they get such special highlighting. I should say I do like how top level troll posts get put at the bottom for reddit.

Re:PG: What's your current take on reddit's comment system? by deramisan on Saturday July 14, 2007 @07:01PM (#34264)
It bugs me that downmodded comments trash karma - political disagreements often get downmodded not because they aren't valid, but because someone disagrees fundamentally. That doesn't seem right.
Re:PG: What's your current take on reddit's comment system? by icky on Monday July 23, 2007 @08:29AM (#36081)
Reddit comments DO NOT AFFECT KARMA.

Only submitted articles do.

I have no idea how you got any different idea into your head, but it was not through observation of reality.

Re:PG: What's your current take on reddit's comment system? by mlgoss on Monday July 23, 2007 @01:06PM (#36138)
You can set the threshold or turn off the hiding of downmodded comments on reddit.