News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by barrkel on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:01AM (#3392490)
Incorporation is a privilege granted by society; and property rights are never absolute. What you state is extremely individualistic, but it is unrealistic and naive for the same reason. I understand your exhortation, but it does not amount to an argument. For example, most large companies with broad shareholder bases have no owner interests that you can easily point to; the shareholder base has collective action problems, and frequently cannot meaningfully affect the company.

I think you're at risk of deriving an ought from an is yourself. You take capitalist ownership structures, which exist for the hopeful progress of society at large, but you infer an ought from them, that the only thing that is fair is that ownership is absolute in control over what it owns.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by alexqgb on Monday December 26, 2011 @07:10AM (#3392775)
This is a much more civilized response than my initial reaction, which was "go fuck yourself, mhartl".

The reason for that indignation was, as you pointed out, the obvious truth that without society's extension of limited legal liability, there would be no business in the first place - or, at least, not one with the scale and structure of a publicly traded company. And no, society does not grant this liability protection for free. Nor does it expect to get the short end of the deal. It has a stake in the outcome, and it expects that stake to be rewarded - no less than an investor expects a return on his capital.

mhartl's implication that "only shareholders have any legitimate interest" represents a trifecta of ignorance (of the law) ingratitude (for what it grants) and arrogance (in assuming that his counter-party is irrelevant). It is supremely egocentric and inevitably destructive.

You see the same warped sense of self expressed by people who go around saying "I'm a job creator" as though they were god-like individuals who combined - in a single person - holy trinity of supply, demand, and the ability to connect them that comprise any given job. In reality, jobs - like economic growth - are a product of several interactions that create a favorable situation for employment. No one person or organization controls all of them, or even (in most cases) a majority of them.

What these "job creators" can safely say is "I hire and fire." That's a much more honest description, and one that clearly implies the existence of factors outside their control about which they simply make judgements. Their role is good and necessary, but it is not creative in the sense of having invented, built, or authored a thing. More importantly, people who hire and fire well (aka "managers") are acutely aware of the broader milieu in which they operate, the extent to which they depend on it, and the degree to which their own well-being depends on the health of those around them.

Obliviousness to this vital interdependency remains deeply stupid. And unlike a temporary impairment (e.g. getting very drunk) or a moral impairment (e.g. a propensity to steal), the ethical blindness it represents is not something that the people who have it are usually aware of. Nor is it something about which they can easily be made aware. They simply lack the frame of reference needed to understand what they lack. Just consider colorblindness; a person who cannot see a limited part of the spectrum can still grasp the idea of color, and can make allowances for what they can't detect directly. But a person who has no sense of color whatsoever has no point of reference they can use to grasp even the idea of color.

When it comes to responsibility, people like mhartl fall into the latter camp. Their minds simply cannot process the idea of social reciprocity. That is to say, they have no real ethics. In extreme cases, this makes them properly sociopathic. If you find yourself working with a person like this, distance yourself as soon as possible. They are dangerous, entirely self-serving, and prolonged exposure will get you hurt.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by bricestacey on Monday December 26, 2011 @10:23AM (#3393062)
I think you may have valid criticisms, but were out of line to call mhartl a man of "no real ethics, a sociopath, dangerous, self-serving, and someone to distance yourself from." I have only exchanged emails briefly, regarding his book, and he is nothing short of an honest, well-intentioned, and generous man.

Let's avoid the attacks and keep the conversation civil.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by alexqgb on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:30PM (#3393699)
Please note, I did not call mhartl a man of "no real ethics, a sociopath, dangerous, self-serving, and someone to distance yourself from."

I did say his ethics are weak, and I stand by this. Assuming he believes what he says, his anti-social position on the obligations of the corporation speak for themselves. And I did note that, when carried to the extreme, blind spots like the one shared by mhartl do, in fact, produce the litany of wrong that I mentioned (a position I REALLY stand by, having worked for people I wish I hadn't).

I did not, however, say that mhartl himself represents these extremes. That's an important distinction. And if, as you say, he is an honest, well-intentioned, and generous man, then perhaps he arrived at his current position for some benign reason - a lack of careful thought, or maybe an insufficiency of experience. In any case, people who share his lack of concern have become responsible for some very major damage. This aspect of his thought is not incidental to the problem, it IS the problem. Or, rather, it is an essential component of the problem.

Just consider what the OP is arguing. The faults of shareholder capitalism are not minor. Indeed, they have demonstrated a destructive power that has decimated companies, portfolios, and - at this late stage in the experiment - entire economies. This is not "creative destruction". It's shoot-yourself-in-both-feet-then-wonder-why-you-can't-walk destruction. And while we can demonstrate how bad it is now, there was no need to learn by doing. Had we considered the ethical failures inherent in mhartl's arguments sooner and more seriously, the crash of 2007/8 may have never come to pass.

Again, we're talking about a line of thought that has produced deep and lasting harm in the lives of billions - but not without racking up billion dollar gains for a microscopic minority who have responded by using their inordinate power to capture and corrupt the government we all depend on. This is really bad stuff. Historically speaking, this trajectory reduces citizens to subjects, and the weakest to slaves. Whether he realizes it or not, thinking like martl's supported the wrong side of political situation that has made itself the dominant evil of the day.

It needs to end, and the generation that does end it will probably spend the remainder of their lives cleaning up the mess. The sooner people disabuse themselves of the notions that allowed shareholder capitalism to spin so wildly out of control in the first place, the better off everyone is going to be - mhartl included.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by jacoblyles on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @12:16AM (#3394908)
In my experience, people who can't accept that others might hold beliefs that differ from theirs for good reasons are giant assholes.
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by notahacker on Monday December 26, 2011 @09:11AM (#3392923)
The original argument was against facile generations like "businesses ought to maximise shareholder value" and "businesses ought to aim to create more customers, which the author quite reasonably pointed out didn't apply to his own business ventures. If anything, it's a criticism of "sociopathic" maxims like Milton Friedman's infamous "there is one and only one social responsibility of business–to use it resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits": the implication is that other objectives like paying himself a higher salary, working less, giving his books away for free on the internet to help everyone learn Rails or aiming for abstract "socially responsible" goals need not be subordinate to supposedly universal business imperatives of growing profits or customer bases.

The ethical implications of limited liability laws (one ought not to take credit one has no expectation of repaying; one ought not to mislead investors) are a tangential issue; a list of things an owner ought not to do with their business (see also: sell crack to kids, sexually harass staff, murder competitors) can happily exist in the absence of some overriding objective business owners ought to follow.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by j_baker on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:35PM (#3393871)
This is a strawman. Clearly mhartl is doing something good for society. If his goal in helping society is so that he can build a pool of money he can dive into like Scrooge McDuck, why do you care? Is helping society only good if the person who does a good deed only cares for helping starving orphans and lost puppies?

The only time having self interest is wrong is if that self interest hurts society. What's wrong with furthering your own interest if society benefits in the process?

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by Tycho on Monday December 26, 2011 @05:39PM (#3394124)
Society, being an abstract entity, cannot articulate what it actually wants. What we know is at lawmakers have granted a certain condition of limited-liability to encourage enterprise. Everyone is aware of this limited liability and is free to trade with those who claim it as they see fit. There is no further debt to society and it's not a 'privilege.'
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by zeteo on Monday December 26, 2011 @05:37PM (#3394115)
"society does not grant [...] protection for free. Nor does it expect to get the short end of the deal. It [...] expects [its] stake to be rewarded [...] mhartl's implication [...] represents [...] arrogance [...] It is supremely egocentric [...]"

There is a certain amusement in seeing a lecture about what "society" surely thinks and expects from all of us followed up with accusations of arrogance and egocentricity.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by forensic on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:00PM (#3393781)
Limited liability was initially intended to protect minority shareholders from being responsible for the misconduct of the general partners. Now it has been extended to general partners as well which is just stupid.
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by jacoblyles on Monday December 26, 2011 @04:00PM (#3393926)
Who is this "society" you speak of? Am I society? Can I tell businesses what I want them to do?
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by mhartl on Monday December 26, 2011 @05:35PM (#3394113)
I'm really just asserting a tautology: Business owners determine what their businesses should do. Given the current legal status of corporations, the question "What should a company do?" is not ethical in nature (ought); it is a matter of fact (is): companies can, within the constraints imposed by law, do whatever their owners want them to do. There are certainly salient ethical questions here—"Which laws should governments enforce to constrain businesses' behavior?", for example, or "If I want to benefit others, what should I have my business do?"—but they lie outside the scope of my original comment.
Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by barrkel on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @10:06AM (#3395964)
The people who have executive power in the leadership structure of companies control what companies do. When ownership is diversified, business owners do not determine what their businesses do; your "tautology" is actually false, obviously so with more than a cursory examination of the world as it is. I myself am a part-owner of ARM, for example, but I have zero effective control over them.

And the question as to what should a company do is very definitely an ethical one. Some people try to argue that ethics only apply to companies in so far as they apply to the people that form the company; but others do not. Because the question isn't "what can a company do within the constraints of law", the question is actually what ought a company do.

Companies help match supply and demand where the supply or demand or both are divided and scattered enough that they can't be efficiently matched through individual contracts. But in this formulation, just like free markets, they have no moral content. The mere fact that there is demand for something does not imply that it is good that the demand is satisfied with supply. Lynch mobs frequently have short bursts of popularity, and they demand someone be lynched; irrelevant of whether they are legal or not, it should be clear that the fact of the demand does not amount to an ethical justification.

So when we ask what ought a company do, it is not enough to look at ownership structures; nor is it enough that we look at the operations of the company in providing supply to market demands. Merely following the law is not enough either; many immoral things are permitted by the law (to the point that later, the law changes), and many moral acts are taxed or prohibited by the law, for various formulations of morality. But more importantly, the law is itself informed by the ethical question over what ought companies do.

For example, it may be the case that child labour is legal in country X, and company A employs children in country X to meet supply for products in country Y, where such child labour is illegal and everybody agrees that it is unethical. By your formulation, there is no way to argue that company A is violating ethical norms. At best, you would suggest that shareholders - e.g. people with pensions, ultimately - should be held ethically responsible. You'll forgive me for thinking that that sounds rather ridiculous.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by mhartl on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @02:53PM (#3397116)
The people who have executive power in the leadership structure of companies control what companies do.

The leadership structure is determined by the Chief Executive, who is appointed by the Board of Directors, who are elected by the shareholders, i.e., the owners. Q.E.D. (Lest you accuse me again of naïveté, I'm aware that there remains a principal-agent problem (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal-agent_problem); when an angel becomes available to serve as CEO, I suggest doing your level best to get him the job.)

By your formulation, there is no way to argue that company A is violating ethical norms.

The whole point of my formulation is that it is silent on ethical questions. If you find it unethical that Company A uses child labor, you can buy from their competitors, or organize a boycott, or lobby to make their practice illegal—and I might well join you. Supposing that Company A is a standard joint-stock company, your actions would serve to align their interests (maximize value) with yours (be ethical according to your criteria). There is no conflict between your actions of protest and the statement "The company owners determine its actions"; as categories, is and ought are orthogonal.

should be held ethically responsible

Note the passive voice in this statement: "be held responsible". By whom? When people say that corporations should "be held responsible", what they means is, "We want to hold corporations responsible [is] according to our system of ethics [ought]." In other words, stripped of all camouflage, it is a naked grab for power. It's a generally well-intentioned power grab, of course, and depending on your system of ethics you might consider their achieving power to be a good thing. But Robespierre had good intentions, too, and the road to hell, etc.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by barrkel on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @05:36PM (#3397738)
You acknowledge the principle/agent problem, yet you pretend it doesn't exist in your QED; your demonstrandum was not convincingly demonstrated.

What if company A has a monopoly owing to being cheaper than any possible competition that does not use child labour? Would your argument for introducing a law against it not be an ethical argument governing the permissible actions of companies?

We want to hold corporations responsible [is] according to our system of ethics [ought]." In other words, stripped of all camouflage, it is a naked grab for power

Well yes, I do rather prefer government to anarchy. I'm sorry to say that if you see this as a "naked grab for power", I have little more to add, and am unwilling to continue a conversation with you. This is because, unless I'm mistaken, you are denying the very basis of democratic government ("we", the majority) in defense of something much more dangerous (the oligopoly of wealth and executive power). Someone who would do that is not someone I would trust; it is someone I'd rather shun.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by mhartl on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @02:18AM (#3398978)
the very basis of democratic government ("we", the majority)

Come now—you don't even believe this. The majority used to support legal chattel slavery. Did that make slavery right? Killing Native Americans and taking their land was pretty popular, too. And what about the overwhelming popular support for the Anschluss Österreichs that brought Austria under Nazi rule? Und so weiter.

You can believe in ethical government, or you can believe in the ethical principle of "majority rule", but you can't believe in both. Think about that the next time you slam someone for questioning "democracy".

If you shun me, it's not because I'm dangerous or untrustworthy, but rather because you are a Jedi and I am a Sith. (Suffice to say you've been exposed to a lot of anti-Sith propaganda.) Don't worry—I, too, was once a Jedi, and I don't take it personally. Luckily, it's never too late to come over to the Dark Side.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by j_baker on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:25PM (#3393853)
Perhaps the grandparent isn't making that great of an argument. But at the same time, I don't see you doing anything but arguing. And yet, I have no idea what you're arguing for. I assume that you're making the case that companies need to be more focused on collective action, but I don't really see any alternative vision compared to the grandparent.

That said, I don't think collectivism and individuality are mutually exclusive. If a company can be individualistic in a way that benefits society, what's the problem? Clearly there need to be some limits to what company owners can get away with. That's why society has laws. But it's especially naive to think that companies can be structures that act solely for the good of society with no benefit to the people that have invested in and work for them. Clearly, there needs to be some level of individualism granted to the people who make a company work. Otherwise, you'll have companies that spend so much time focusing on the good of everyone that they end up delivering for no one.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by barrkel on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @02:03PM (#3396900)
In a single term: stakeholder theory. I do think there needs to be some balance; not necessarily along collectivist lines, but rather with some thought applied to the kind of society we want to live in, and the kind of fairness and justice we want to see in our lives and the lives of our children. So I am hostile to absolutist approaches to ownership and the firm, particularly since we are all only here temporarily, and everything we think we own, we are just renting.

In my view, capitalism is justified in so far as it motivates value creation and production that leaves everyone better off, in a just way, rather than as something which follows from underlying principles around ownership and control of capital. That is, capitalism is a means to an end, not an end in itself; and when this means turns out to be unjust, it should be changed and regulated, rather than treated as sacred.

Re:The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value by dextorious on Monday December 26, 2011 @07:08AM (#3392774)
"""What you state is extremely individualistic, but it is unrealistic and naive for the same reason."""

Actually not at all. It just takes a certain type of society that wants to have and enforces such norms.