News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russia’s apparent resilience is being kept up by policy t... by bell-cot on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:18AM (#33922993)
Yes and no. For most of history, conquest of pre-industrial agrarian societies was generally an excellent idea...politically and economically, that is. See any good history of (say) the economics of the Roman Empire. Or the British Empire.

That's part of why WWI was so hellishly destructive for Europe - national leaders, military planners, educated elites, etc. really didn't get that modern(-ish) industrialized warfare was profoundly different from "the good old days", and they made endless bad decisions based on obsolete "wisdom".

Re:Russia’s apparent resilience is being kept up by policy t... by clnq on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:29AM (#33923166)
Historically, yes and no. I agree. But recent wars look much more like All Quiet on the Western Front than conquests of the Roman Empire.
Re:Russia’s apparent resilience is being kept up by policy t... by jcranmer on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:39AM (#33923301)
The deadliest war before WW1 was the Napoleonic Wars (which essentially set up the then-existing European system), and before that, the Thirty Years' War and similar wars of religion were incredibly destructive.

When were "the good old days" you were referring to?

Re:Russia’s apparent resilience is being kept up by policy t... by bell-cot on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:56AM (#33923558)
For the winners (recall that the ruling classes were rather indifferent to the deaths of large numbers of the less-well-born) many of those wars turned out pretty well. In "let's play Prisoner's Dilemma" terms, the payoff matrix for "Go to War?" was, for the ruling classes, far more favorable back then. (Vs. for modern industrialized warfare.)

Add the Mongol Empire and Russian Empire to my "war & conquest worked out pretty well for 'em" list.

Re:Russia’s apparent resilience is being kept up by policy t... by bell-cot on Saturday December 10, 2022 @10:46AM (#33933566)
Clarification - by "Russian Empire" here, I mean the old Empire - say, from the Battle of Kulikovo (1380) up until the Crimean War (~1855). The latter was against several modern-ish, getting-industrialized major powers.

Yes, plenty of parallels can be drawn between the Crimean War and the current Russian "special military operation" in Ukraine. The former ended with the Treaty of Paris on March 30, 1856 - which was a very clear Russian defeat.