News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by jraph on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:42AM (#33918321)
Good luck.

For others, let this serve as another lesson to never sign in somewhere with any account if you can help it.

This week there's also this other person that says there are soft locked into Google because they signed in with Google to many places.

Go to the trouble of creating a regular account. It's less trouble in the end. (here it was not possible, but of course, it looks like it was a scam, so maybe it's a red flag anyway)

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by DarrenDev on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:26AM (#33918625)
You can't always avoid it.

I had an incident only a week ago where I had to sign up to Snyk and the only way to do so was to use a third party sign in -- no option to create a new account using email.

The end results was me signing in using a Google account tied to the client, resulting in an immediate account disabled message from Google. It took a week to get the account re-opened, but left a bad taste in my mouth. If a billion dollar company can't be bothered to create their own sign in, what can we do?

I was so pissed off at the time that I wanted to open a support ticket with Snyk and vent, but of course, couldn't find any way to do that on their website.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by Tepix on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:32AM (#33919012)
The best way to fix the problem is not to sign up to such companies and complain instead. If you can't find a feedback form, perhaps they are not interested in feedback? In that case there's always twitter.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by stainablesteel on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:22PM (#33924665)
just heard of snyk and googled

> Snyk is a Boston-based cybersecurity company specializing in cloud computing...

how is it secure [or wise] to require you to share an external login?

that's infuriating

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by JohnFen on Saturday December 10, 2022 @10:47AM (#33933575)
> You can't always avoid it.

I've managed to. It does mean that some services are unavailable to me, but that's life.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by jraph on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:41AM (#33918721)
Maybe a way to handle this kind of situation would be to create a dedicated Google account?

(I haven't encountered the situation myself, didn't try it)

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by glogla on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:09AM (#33918882)
Google is known to link accounts by ip address, name similarity, phone numbers, emails, etc. There are for example stories of companies with their Google Cloud disabled because former employee using their personal account pushed app Google didn't like to Play Store.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by angry_octet on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:06AM (#33919241)
And anyway you need a phone number for each account now. What a PITA, by design of course.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by benplumley on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:03AM (#33918848)
Tailscale only allows you to create a new account by signing in with Google, Microsoft or GitHub. It's a real shame because it's a great service otherwise, but this left a very sour taste.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by Tepix on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:31AM (#33919007)
I don't use services that force me to give up privacy like that. A VPN service no less? That's almost funny.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by franga2000 on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:40AM (#33919064)
Tailscale is a real VPN, not a privacy proxy using VPN tech. VPNs have nothing to do with privacy, this is no worse than any other service doing it.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by mkl on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:01AM (#33919212)
Virtual Private Networks are all about privacy. They aren't necessarily about anonymity though.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by newaccount74 on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:30AM (#33919392)
The term "VPN service" has become synonymous with "proxy service that allows circumventing region locks that is implemented using VPN". These services are often pretty scammy and have come in the news often for harvesting user data.

These VPN services have little to do with the traditional meaning of a VPN. They don't provide a private network at all, they just use VPN tech to implement a proxy service.

Tailscale is not a "VPN service" in that sense, they actually provide software for setting up a VPN between computers you control.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by mkl on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:38AM (#33919447)
Yes, that's what my comment is about: Tailscale is about privacy from the outside world for your network, not the privacy and anonymity VPN proxy services claim to provide.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by franga2000 on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:19PM (#33925381)
Something being private and having privacy mean very different things in practice. I can stand in the middle of a field that is my private land, but have no privacy from people on the adjacent road looking at what I'm doing or listening to what I'm saying.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by BossingAround on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:13AM (#33919287)
Private != privacy. Private corporate networks do not guarantee privacy either.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by mkl on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:21AM (#33919334)
They do guarantee privacy from the outside world. They don't necessarily guarantee anonymity or privacy within the network.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by allarm on Sunday December 11, 2022 @02:08AM (#33940888)
No they don’t. VPNs allow _access_ to a set of subnets that might not be accessible otherwise - normally from external to private. Even though usually vpn traffic is encrypted it’s not a rule or an inherent property of VPNs - see GRE and PPTP for example.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by humanistbot on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:48PM (#33924245)
> VPNs have nothing to do with privacy

Don't feed the trolls.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by dismalpedigree on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:23AM (#33920138)
Yep. Single reason we don’t use them anymore. Great service, but we don’t have corporate MS, GitHub or Google accounts.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by everybodyknows on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:19AM (#33922161)
Any alternatives you can recommend?
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by dismalpedigree on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:35PM (#33927953)
I’m a big fan of Nebula (Slacks project maintained by Defined Networking)
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by gdhdjdvr on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:10AM (#33918887)
Head scale FTW? I mea n you need to self host it and deal with all that... But it is your network...
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by kelnos on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:59PM (#33925802)
It does look like they support SAML and OIDC. I think the idea here is that many (most?) Tailscale users will be corporations, and most corporations would rather integrate Tailscale access with their existing auth system, and not have an extra employee account to deal with that needs to be disabled when the employee leaves the company.

That does make things harder for small shops where things are more ad-hoc, or an individual hobbyist who wants to use it. But not sure how much of Tailscale's market consists of people like that, or if Tailscale even cares that much about that segment. No judgment if they don't; that's a perfectly reasonable decision to make.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by seany on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:13AM (#33922057)
You can add your own external provider. I'm using them with Okta at the moment.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by glogla on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:07AM (#33918872)
Oh that's a shame.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by stickfigure on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:43AM (#33921676)
If you want anonymity, why not just create new Google/Microsoft/GitHub accounts? How is that different from creating a new "Tailscale account" - presumably with what, your existing gmail address?
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by plugin-baby on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:17AM (#33918924)
> For others, let this serve as another lesson to never sign in somewhere with any account if you can help it.

+1 to this. I got locked out of my StackOverflow account because they stopped supporting my auth provider, I think a couple of years ago.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by CannisterFlux on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:34AM (#33920191)
Not sure if you care any more after a couple of years, but https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/309839

This question is about a Facebook account that was deleted but it should apply to OpenID providers that go away too. The mods' comments seem to indicate that the "Contact Us" link gets you through to a human that may be able to help as well.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by nashashmi on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:37AM (#33918689)
I came across the same realization after disconnecting from twitter. I am signed into multiple places using twitter. Even though I have deactivated my account, I have to reactivate every time to login on a site like disqus.

FB, Twit, Goog, need to separate oauth login from the rest of their service.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by anshumankmr on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:16AM (#33919310)
You say the morally correct thing, but being a Managed Identity Provider is gonna cost loads of money and they really have no business incentive to do this, in fact it may be negative for some of their KPIs like the no. of sign ups they have on their site.

The best course of action would have been for you to de-couple your Identity Provider from your account completely, I have done that over a course of a few months. I have de-coupled myself from Google Sign in on my most frequented sites, using Email + a Password manager + 2FA wherever its supported. though I have also have even used Apple's sign in for some apps

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by fancyfish on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:02AM (#33922784)
Can you trigger the reset password flow on disqus, etc? That’s what I’ve done on a few sites to disconnect from 3rd party oauth and use email instead.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by nashashmi on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:12PM (#33927070)
I reactivated to disconnect disqus. But twitter does not share email address with sites so i could not do forgot password. That is why it was my preferred login technique.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by nashashmi on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:44AM (#33918739)
Anyone know how to list which sites I used my twitter login on?
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by franga2000 on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:41AM (#33919074)
Don't know about twitter, but most providers have some sort of "Applications" tab in the user settings that lists every site you gave an oauth grant to.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by forgotpwd16 on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:28AM (#33920984)
https://twitter.com/settings/connected_apps

Kinda deeply nested into settings submenus.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by nashashmi on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:09AM (#33921351)
It shows blank for me. And I know have had more than three sites that used it.

I think that is for third party apps that help you tweet. I never used any.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by pmontra on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:12AM (#33918518)
There is no way to create a regular account on Travis. It's only sign in with GitHub and a few others that they added recently.

https://app.travis-ci.com/signin

I understand why they are doing it, because they have to pull from GitHub, but it's not the only way. They could create a regular user on GitHub and ask people to let that user pull from their repositories. Obviously it's more trouble for the user, it would harm adoption and growth, that user could be banned and halt all of Travis.

Travis is the only site I have ever used in that way, because I have a customer that uses it. With hindsight I think that I should create a per customer account on GitHub, just in case something bad happens to Travis.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by toastal on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:07AM (#33919644)
I believe it goes against the ToS for Microsoft GitHub to have more than one account per human.
Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by pmontra on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:11PM (#33924530)
https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/github-terms/github-t...

> One person or legal entity may maintain no more than one free Account

This means that for nearly all of us it is one account per person.

The rules are more relaxed for corporations

https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/github-terms/github-c...

> A User’s login may not be shared by multiple people.

and that's it.

So there could be [email protected], [email protected], etc. Probably only the joe in his current company can login because the others have revoked its access.

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by devjab on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:39AM (#33918699)
> With hindsight I think that I should create a per customer account on GitHub, just in case something bad happens to Travis.

Is it too late to do that?

My immediate line of thinking to this thread of "sometimes you have to use an account to sign in" was that then you'll need to create a new account specifically to sign into that service. If you have to sign into that service. Maybe I'm weird, but I tend to even use a DuckDuckGo e-mail when I sign up, so that a specific service is in no way linked directly to me and so that I can stop forwarding e-mails from any specific service.

To be fair, I sort of wonder why Github has an API that allows 3rd parties to star projects with your account. I get that the author of this post on HN is responsible for not reading the "clicked through pages" part of the processes and that they should consider themselves sort of lucky it was only abused for star farming, but why do we have that sort of "facebooky" functionality on Github in the first place?

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by fedorareis on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:24AM (#33918960)
A lot of the APIs that allow for things like starring projects have been around for a long time. Before GitHub introduced an official mobile app there were a number of unofficial mobile apps that used those types of APIs to give users a “fully functional” GitHub app.

I would say though that if GitHub is allowing requests like that through the API then they should be banning the API token and the account it was issued to if it uses the API maliciously

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by BHSPitMonkey on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:28PM (#33925502)
> With hindsight I think that I should create a per customer account on GitHub, just in case something bad happens to Travis.

In case you missed it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33906591

Re:Ask HN: Developer abused “sign in with GitHub”? by matkoniecz on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:00AM (#33919593)
Or do not do

> i logged in, clicked through a bunch of pages because its the same drill everytime

GitHub is clearly listing list of permissions, and yes - I check it before accepting log in and in some cases have not granted permission because scope was overly large.