I had an incident only a week ago where I had to sign up to Snyk and the only way to do so was to use a third party sign in -- no option to create a new account using email.
The end results was me signing in using a Google account tied to the client, resulting in an immediate account disabled message from Google. It took a week to get the account re-opened, but left a bad taste in my mouth. If a billion dollar company can't be bothered to create their own sign in, what can we do?
I was so pissed off at the time that I wanted to open a support ticket with Snyk and vent, but of course, couldn't find any way to do that on their website.
> Snyk is a Boston-based cybersecurity company specializing in cloud computing...
how is it secure [or wise] to require you to share an external login?
that's infuriating
I've managed to. It does mean that some services are unavailable to me, but that's life.
(I haven't encountered the situation myself, didn't try it)
These VPN services have little to do with the traditional meaning of a VPN. They don't provide a private network at all, they just use VPN tech to implement a proxy service.
Tailscale is not a "VPN service" in that sense, they actually provide software for setting up a VPN between computers you control.
Don't feed the trolls.
That does make things harder for small shops where things are more ad-hoc, or an individual hobbyist who wants to use it. But not sure how much of Tailscale's market consists of people like that, or if Tailscale even cares that much about that segment. No judgment if they don't; that's a perfectly reasonable decision to make.
+1 to this. I got locked out of my StackOverflow account because they stopped supporting my auth provider, I think a couple of years ago.
This question is about a Facebook account that was deleted but it should apply to OpenID providers that go away too. The mods' comments seem to indicate that the "Contact Us" link gets you through to a human that may be able to help as well.
FB, Twit, Goog, need to separate oauth login from the rest of their service.
The best course of action would have been for you to de-couple your Identity Provider from your account completely, I have done that over a course of a few months. I have de-coupled myself from Google Sign in on my most frequented sites, using Email + a Password manager + 2FA wherever its supported. though I have also have even used Apple's sign in for some apps
Kinda deeply nested into settings submenus.
I think that is for third party apps that help you tweet. I never used any.
https://app.travis-ci.com/signin
I understand why they are doing it, because they have to pull from GitHub, but it's not the only way. They could create a regular user on GitHub and ask people to let that user pull from their repositories. Obviously it's more trouble for the user, it would harm adoption and growth, that user could be banned and halt all of Travis.
Travis is the only site I have ever used in that way, because I have a customer that uses it. With hindsight I think that I should create a per customer account on GitHub, just in case something bad happens to Travis.
> One person or legal entity may maintain no more than one free Account
This means that for nearly all of us it is one account per person.
The rules are more relaxed for corporations
https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/github-terms/github-c...
> A User’s login may not be shared by multiple people.
and that's it.
So there could be [email protected], [email protected], etc. Probably only the joe in his current company can login because the others have revoked its access.
Is it too late to do that?
My immediate line of thinking to this thread of "sometimes you have to use an account to sign in" was that then you'll need to create a new account specifically to sign into that service. If you have to sign into that service. Maybe I'm weird, but I tend to even use a DuckDuckGo e-mail when I sign up, so that a specific service is in no way linked directly to me and so that I can stop forwarding e-mails from any specific service.
To be fair, I sort of wonder why Github has an API that allows 3rd parties to star projects with your account. I get that the author of this post on HN is responsible for not reading the "clicked through pages" part of the processes and that they should consider themselves sort of lucky it was only abused for star farming, but why do we have that sort of "facebooky" functionality on Github in the first place?
I would say though that if GitHub is allowing requests like that through the API then they should be banning the API token and the account it was issued to if it uses the API maliciously
In case you missed it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33906591
> i logged in, clicked through a bunch of pages because its the same drill everytime
GitHub is clearly listing list of permissions, and yes - I check it before accepting log in and in some cases have not granted permission because scope was overly large.
For others, let this serve as another lesson to never sign in somewhere with any account if you can help it.
This week there's also this other person that says there are soft locked into Google because they signed in with Google to many places.
Go to the trouble of creating a regular account. It's less trouble in the end. (here it was not possible, but of course, it looks like it was a scam, so maybe it's a red flag anyway)