News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by Spivak on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:20AM (#33880195)
This is a non-story: "Artists will sell art made with new kind of paintbrush."

> But AI is different because it was trained on other people's images

Same as any other artist learning a breadth of styles from other people's works.

> But it's copyright infringement

Only if it's copyright infringement. If you use tool to make infringing image then it's infringing. Artists have been able to trace since the sun was invented.

> But you might not know it's copyright infringement

That's how it works when you buy art from anywhere. All you get is a statement from the artist or indemnification if you have a real real legal team.

> But the artist themselves might not know

Won't be the first or last time an artist has reproduced an work from a memory they thought was original.

> But I think the model itself is infringing material

Nobody knows that for sure. We'll see when it's tested in court.

Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by randombits0 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:02AM (#33881050)
It’s either an infringement or it’s not copyrightable. Pick one.

Only creative works are copyrightable.

Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by sereguze on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:06AM (#33918098)
Why would it just be one of the first two options and never the 3rd option you presented?
Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by randombits0 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:47PM (#33950283)
Only humans get copyrights.
Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by sereguze on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:05PM (#34023000)
a human used the tool
Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by randombits0 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @12:44AM (#34145524)
Point to the creative expression fixed in a tangible media authored by a human. Do AI queries qualify as creative expression?
Re:Adobe will sell AI-made stock images by sereguze on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @07:18PM (#34240070)
I’m playing a bit of devils advocate to see where you draw the line. For me personally I actually think nothing is creative enough to have the results owned or more to the point it’s not the effort that goes in but the literal act of creation is copying that makes something new property ie I’m against non contractual intellectual property altogether and so don’t need to draw a line based off of the action itself but instead ask what the people buying the art agreed to when they pay for an act of media creation. I’m not trying to convince you to adopt this position. I am just curious