Unfortunately even then a boot campers “experience” is quite limited but many come out of their program believing they are equals to more experienced mid/senior level programmers which results in those in the industry having animosity to those individuals. I think this explains the general “negative tone” you see in this comment section.
Are boot camps bad? No, I think they are quite useful but I think we need to acknowledge that they really only effectively create a pipeline of junior developers and replace the need for corporations to have internal education/training programs.
It seems the core of your argument is not that they are inexperienced, but rather that the bootcamps somehow convince them they are not and this leads to friction in the positions they seek and the expectations around the work they're capable of accomplishing.
Yes, I personally believe that the animosity isn’t usually targeted at the fact that boot camp grads went through boot camp. Hell, programmers are most commonly self taught using free online resources for the majority of topics. My impression is because the boot camp is sold as a “get programming experience quick scheme” that most candidates would still be entry level after their program but are led to believe they are more senior.
I think it's worse than average - lots of strong opinions being bandied about. If I had to make up a score it's somewhere slightly above Google shutting down Stadia and significantly below FB / Cambridge Analytica scandal.
Note that I am not saying that HN is now less neutral--it may be that the current level of optimism vs. cynicism maps better to reality.
That said, I think more optimism is generally better (for motivating action) if you want to start a new business or build a new technology; more realism is generally better if you want to go down an established path or join a venture purely as an employee; and more cynicism is better if you want to be a rabid online commentator (joke!).
The largest companies on the planet, that the majority of us here earn a living from, directly or indirectly, are essentially data gathering advertising companies. I feel like the lack of optimism is justified.
Bloom Tech (formally Lambda School) was actually an HN favorite in the early years. Paul Graham spoke highly of them on Twitter and many of us held them up as an example of next generation education done right.
My first hints that something was not right came not from HN, but from talking to actual Lambda School students in the real world. They did not have good things to say about the program. This theme continued in online discussions as more and more anecdotes came out.
That’s when the HN sentiment started changing. By now, anyone following this story has heard countless anecdotes from former students who regret their time there. They may have improved over time (explaining your positive anecdote, I suppose?), but it’s hard to argue that they were always good when even the top comments on this thread are from former BloomTech students talking about how they regret their time there. It’s not really “knee jerk reactions” when it’s coming from the students themselves.
The Bloom Tech founder is a prolific social media influencer. He’s very good at dropping into these situations and talking his way out of bad history and dismissing any arguments against their programs. I bought it for a long time, but I’ve heard too many first-person anecdotes from their students to really trust anything coming out of the company any more. They are too strong at marketing and grassroots promotion.
Meta comment: It's intersting to see how many comments on any Bloomtech/Lambda post are very knee-jerk in nature, mostly negative some positive. And to be clear, I'd say most are thoughtful. The thing that strikes me is that I can't tell if this is normal HN tenor for a tech story or if it's just because I have opinions on the subject. The only other stories witg comments that strike me as remotely similar are those dealing with privacy.
So an ask, if Bloomtech is something you don't care about, neither positively nor negatively, do you find the comments for this article of average "pitch"?