News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Ghosts by jakewins on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:01AM (#33829411)
I agree with this.

My question was about the blog posts assertion that something using environment variables to pass information was using a "ghost", but something like a command line option isn't.

I guess, maybe the difference is in when and where the env var is specified. If you do something like

```

FOO=bar

<hundreds of lines of bash>

myapp # uses FOO

``

Then I think the blog post author has a point - there's "hidden" information in the environment/context that the callee expects and will use. If you copied just the `myapp` line and stuck it somewhere else, it would lose the implicit `FOO` it expects to have.

Vs something like

```

FOO=bar

<hundreds of lines of bash>

myapp --foo="${FOO}"

```

or

```

FOO=bar

<hundreds of lines of bash>

FOO="${FOO}" myapp # at least this way it's explicit!

```

There are no comments on this comment yet.