News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:10AM (#33827057)
Free speech is about allowing any idea to be expressed. Spam is not an idea, but a way of expressing something, so it's not inherently against free speech to restrict it.
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by majormajor on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:28AM (#33827167)
Yet many will complain that what they call "hurt feelings" are irrelevant regarding whether or not their statements were OK and should be welcome. What separates a "way of expressing" from a true "idea"? "Abuse" is not an idea, but a way of expressing something? "You suck" is something of an "idea," but "I hope you die" or "watch out for your kids" if it's not a literally true threat? Not so much... And if it IS a true threat? For that matter... "mockery" is not an idea... "hateful" is not an idea... "insulting" is not an idea? Seems like you can take that definitional dodge to lengths to allow just about any sort of moderation.

(Any given post of spam, basically just unsolicited peer-to-peer advertising, seems evidently an idea, IMO - it's very much something you are supposed to believe and act on. If it's a volume/repetition/thoughtlessness thing, how's that different from a wave of trolling posts?)

Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:34AM (#33827203)
These are all heavily subjective and often used as a code for certain opinions. In current political discourse, “hateful” usually means “disagrees with the woke ideology”, so a statement like “kill all white people” would not be considered hateful, whereas “children under 18 shouln't be allowed to take unnecessary cosmetic surgery” would.
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by majormajor on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:48AM (#33827288)
You carefully avoid saying that "spam" isn't subjective, but if you think it is, your reply wouldn't be relevant, so: I doubt you'll have any luck trying to "objectively" establish a criteria for spam classification that nobody disagrees with.

Or what about the threat examples, since you claim all those categories were subjective? You didn't engage with that one, or many of the others. "I know your kids go to [specific school], watch out"? Subjective? "I'm going to kill you and your family?" Subjective or straight up threat? How about mockery or insults? "Your post is stupid and you are stupid?" Is it subjective that that's insulting? So is it an "idea" or just a particular way of saying I disagree with you? "You are clearly politically motivated and not arguing in good faith?" Maybe that one is actually an idea!

Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:58AM (#33827334)
> You carefully avoid saying that "spam" isn't subjective, but if you think it is, your reply wouldn't be relevant, so: I doubt you'll have any luck trying to "objectively" establish a criteria for spam classification that nobody disagrees with.

Alright. Spam is when you post something to a space where it's not relevant (not really applicable to Twitter since it doesn't have topical spaces), or post something repeatedly without a good reason.

> "I know your kids go to [specific school], watch out"? Subjective? "I'm going to kill you and your family?" Subjective or straight up threat?

Those are specific threats, which are not protected as free speech.

> "Your post is stupid and you are stupid?"

Nothing wrong with saying that, aside from the fact that it's not constructive and you'd be better off explaining why you disagree.

> "You are clearly politically motivated and not arguing in good faith?"

Same as previous.

Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by UncleMeat on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#33829888)
"I know your kids go to [specific school], watch out" isn't a specific threat.
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:27AM (#33830149)
How not? It expresses intention to harm a specific individual at a specific place if a certain implicit condition is met.
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by UncleMeat on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:56AM (#33829872)
Is "shut the fuck up, fa***t" an idea? That's precisely the sort of thing that I see people say shouldn't lead to bans on Twitter.

This is very clearly not just about "expressing ideas." There is very real behavior that is designed entirely to hurt other people and is 100% legal that is at the center of this discussion of online moderation.

Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:29AM (#33830167)
> Is "shut the fuck up, fa**t" an idea? That's precisely the sort of thing that I see people say shouldn't lead to bans on Twitter.

It's not an idea, though I don't see a particular reason to ban it, unless you have a platform like Saidit that generally encourages constructive discussion over baseless insults (which I consider a great idea).

Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by UncleMeat on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:36AM (#33830235)
How does this jive with the claim that free speech is about expressing ideas?
Re:The distinction between free speech as a legal right and ... by xigoi on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:40AM (#33830283)
I'm not saying it goes against free speech to ban this particular sentence. It's just hypocritical if you don't also ban other insults.