Do you think greater selectivity applicants would increase the success rate? I had thought the ISA model would incentivize this, but when I learned lambda was selling ISAs that seemed like it removed this incentive.
I totally saw people who had never coded before succeed, I'm not sure I could pick out in an interview who would do well and who wouldn't. It's a marathon not a sprint.
For the selectivity thing... I'm really not sure. The selling ISAs thing was a bit weird when I learned about. I honestly kinda wonder about the actuarial calcs of it all.
Having tried a number of different ways to do admissions, I can assure you doing interviews is possibly the worst.
As far as ISAs go, it all comes out in the wash. If you create a pool of ISAs and students don't get hired you may have more ISAs but the average ISA is worth less, so the only thing that matters is whether each individual student gets hired. There's no financial wizardry that can let you sell $1 for $2 in the long-run.
For the interview thing, that's just what you were doing at the time. At the rate you were iterating, I'm sure that there's a better process now.
Yeah, some do a remarkably good job of cheating and would get into hiring stats for sure, but I think we've almost entirely cut that out now.
School mentality (and I might add: grifter mentality as well)
However, I've seen students use Stack Overflow and other resources as a source of "program stamps":
- They enter their problem in an Internet search engine.
- Click on the first result with code in it.
- "Stamp it" on their own code: I.e., copy/paste it.
- Using editor/compiler, find any issues by trial and error and fix them so the editor/compiler doesn't complain anymore.
They might try a simple example or two to see if it works. And that's it.
There's not much reflection on their final solution, or on the bits they copy/paste. They don't seem to understand their solution, nor care about that or their problem solving process. They put in effort, they expect a passing grade.
If you only selected students who had been tinkering with writing code for 10 years certainly you'd be successful in doing so, but you'd also eliminate ~90% of those who we have seen become software engineers.
The only way we've found that does it well is to have people actually start writing code and see if they enjoy it. That's why we now have multiple free classes, have a free dropout period once you're in the school, and even have a three-week free trial of the school itself.
The notion that financing ISAs removed the incentives isn't really accurate.
First, most of the time ISAs are financed it's in the form of a loan you have to pay back with interest with an ISA and its repayments as collateral, or it's a sale to a neutral SPV with recourse in the case repayments don't hit a certain threshold.
In the rare instance (we've never done that) schools have been able to sell ISAs full stop, it's been at extreme discounts or based on discounted predicted likelihoods of future revenue, and if those ISAs don't repay the buyers bail and the school trying to sell them is out of business.
Do you think greater selectivity applicants would increase the success rate? I had thought the ISA model would incentivize this, but when I learned lambda was selling ISAs that seemed like it removed this incentive.
Ironically this is not that different from my university experience.
Is this a knock on Lambda School, though?
You can go to MIT but if you never apply your learnings you won't be a good engineer.
At least from what I've heard of bootcamps, you need to really go above and beyond to have similar chances with that route.
I think two things happened over Lambda's life span that effected the quality of the teaching. The first was the initial pool they advertised too. I think I saw the post on Hacker News before everywhere else. I'd wonder if you're more selective from already technical people at the beginning and then sorta widening the net as time goes on to include more people if you could get initial big numbers push followed by more ok numbers.
The instructors I met were all great. I think a lot of that flack went more towards later cohorts or alternative program from the main full webstack track.