News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by rtkwe on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:20AM (#33815840)
That complexity was pretty ruthlessly exploited here in the US by groups that wanted to downplay the issue and end mitigation efforts. Endless takes on "well actually they didn't die of COVID they already had $co-morbidity-x or $co-morbidity-y and that's what REALLY killed them".
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by moduspol on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:42AM (#33816082)
The point is valid. The risks of COVID-19 to people who did not have serious co-morbidities was continuously overstated. This led to measurable misunderstandings among normal people as to the actual risk.

https://catalyst.independent.org/2021/03/24/americans-misinf...

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by belltaco on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:03AM (#33816309)
> 71.6% of adults aged 20 and over are overweight, including obesity. Nearly 40% of American adults aged 20 and over are obese.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by moduspol on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:32AM (#33816697)
You're making my point. The data is from the US.

Somehow, despite high rates of that specific comorbidity, the data shows Americans are hospitalized at dramatically lower rates than Americans estimate.

The post I replied to said:

> That complexity was pretty ruthlessly exploited here in the US by groups that wanted to downplay the issue [...]

Apparently it was not exploited too ruthlessly if surveys show people were still grossly overestimating COVID-19 severity in the population.

Does this result in better COVID-19 policies being made? Who is responsible for this disconnect between reality and what is perceived? How can we fix it?

Or does it even need fixing? Perhaps we'd save more lives if everyone were convinced half of COVID-19 cases were fatal.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by nicoburns on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:57AM (#33816241)
> This led to measurable misunderstandings among normal people as to the actual risk.

You say "normal people" as if not having co-morbidities is more common. But large swathes of the population are old, obese, have asthma or some other co-morbidity.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by moduspol on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:43AM (#33816828)
Apparently despite those large swaths, the actual rate of hospitalization (at least as of September of 2021) is dramatically lower than most people expect.

Why do you think that is?

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by bvhvhfcgxfdf on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:26AM (#33815913)
Yeah it's astonishing how some political parties can win elections while standing on human graves. How hard it is to wear masks and maintain social distancing
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by dustedcodes on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:48AM (#33816137)
Unbearably hard if you ask me. I don't want to socially distance myself from my parents, sister and close friends and it hurts in my heart to see them suffer alone at home and everyone getting visibly depressed over an issue that doesn't affect them directly. I'm all up for keeping others safe, but if it means I have to compromise the mental and physical health of my own family then I couldn't care less about the health of others. Family comes first, no matter what. If my mother who is alone doesn't have any co-morbidities and is in good health (which she is) then why make her unwell? No way.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by Retric on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:20AM (#33816526)
That’s not how social distancing was supposed to work. The goal was to minimize the ability of a disease to spread.

A large party with 100 people is vastly different than a 1v1 meetings. What I think people missed is spending several days with a friend or family member is basically an identical risk as visiting for an afternoon. People could have spent the pandemic couchsurfing as long as the number of contacts over a week was minimized it wasn’t an issue.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by AzzieElbab on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:56AM (#33816226)
Unless you are pointing finger at libertarians, there are plenty of examples of politicians on both sides acting equally irresponsible
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by Retric on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:51AM (#33818915)
So? What’s wrong with complaining about people on both sides of a political divide?

“Evil” may not be eventually distributed, but there is plenty to go around.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by phkahler on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:45AM (#33816107)
But we also had "hit by a bus while infected with covid" count as a covid death. Hospitals got money for covid deaths and that corrupts the numbers the other way. It's a messy thing all around.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by dolinsky on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:57AM (#33816239)
This is just patently false. Unless they were lying on the ground because they were exhausted from Covid and the bus ran them over, Covid would not appear on a death certificate as a co-morbidity.

https://leadstories.com/hoax-alert/2021/10/fact-check-cdc-do...

https://www.aamc.org/news-insights/how-are-covid-19-deaths-c...

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by arcanemachiner on Thursday December 01, 2022 @10:04AM (#33817116)
It was a motorcycle accident, and it was later removed from the list:

https://www.fox35orlando.com/news/fox-35-investigates-questi...

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by belltaco on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:07AM (#33816360)
If that happened, those were more than outweighed by deaths in rural places and others where it wasn't registered as covid deaths. So if anything it's an undercount. Otherwise why would there suddenly be so many excess deaths during the pandemic beyond the ones labeled as due to covid?

> In May 2021, following an analysis by the IHME that the true count of fatalities due to COVID-19 in United States was above 900,000, Anthony Fauci said that he had "no doubt" there was undercounting of COVID-19 deaths.[3] A study published in The Lancet in September 2020 also pointed to significant undercounting.[54][55] Undercounting has been reported from Virginia[56] and California.[57] A 2021 scandal involving New York authorities during the administration of Gov. Andrew Cuomo involved undercounting or an alleged cover-up of COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes in 2020.[58][

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undercounting_of_COVID-19_pand...

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by shlant on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:58AM (#33816245)
wow people are still mindlessly parroting these talking points this far into it.

1. If there were even people who's deaths were grossly misattributed to covid (big if) they were an incredibly, insignificantly rare occurrence. Feel free to provide evidence otherwise.

2. Yes, hospitals get paid for covid deaths - as with EVERY OTHER KIND OF DEATH AND TREATMENT. This is how MEDICARE WORKS.

your comment is so common that both talking points are addressed in one article:

https://fox11online.com/news/fox-11-investigates/fact-check-...

Stop.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by drewcon on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:50AM (#33816163)
No.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by rajin444 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:52AM (#33816174)
Likewise, certain US groups who pointed to total deaths not only ignored comorbidities but also that the average age of death for a Covid victim is past the average age of life expectancy.

They then and still are trying to push vaccines on cohorts that absolutely do not need them (see numerous EU countries who are not doing this).

On top of that, they managed to convince many US citizens that vaccines prevented transmission as part of their efforts to force vaccines on everyone. Go check some past HN threads for a wild ride!

Bonus points are awarded for obesity being a major risk factor that we’ve done 0 to address post Covid despite the absolutely massive benefits we’d see from it - Id wager far outstripping masking or vaccinating. Externalities for thee but not for me, I guess.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by BobbyJo on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:07AM (#33818162)
> Likewise, certain US groups who pointed to total deaths not only ignored comorbidities but also that the average age of death for a Covid victim is past the average age of life expectancy.

Did they ignore them, or were they just not devaluing the lives of the sick and elderly? If 10,000,000 people are dead that would otherwise be living, standing up and saying "but they were old or fat!" has a kind of asshole sting to it, no?

> They then and still are trying to push vaccines on cohorts that absolutely do not need them (see numerous EU countries who are not doing this).

Vaccines aren't just for the people that get them. They are for the people around them as well. I'm a perfectly healthy 35 year old, but I visit my 90 year old grandfather often, and live in a community with many elderly. If the vaccine makes me less likely to transmit, that's good for everyone, whether or not it matters much to me in isolation.

> On top of that, they managed to convince many US citizens that vaccines prevented transmission as part of their efforts to force vaccines on everyone.

They do tho. Maybe not 100%, but to a degree they certainly do.

> Bonus points are awarded for obesity being a major risk factor that we’ve done 0 to address post Covid despite the absolutely massive benefits we’d see from it - Id wager far outstripping masking or vaccinating. Externalities for thee but not for me, I guess.

Not even sure what you're saying here.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by rtkwe on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:41AM (#33818749)
That's what always struck me. Sure the majority are old but they're still dying from COVID not from something else, also there's a significant number that aren't old and if we do nothing because the most at risk portion are already old we're going to lose a lot that aren't. We spend massive amounts of money keeping the elderly alive every day because we recognize that time is important and precious for these people and their families so we don't just dump them at 85 because "well you've outlived most of your cohort already anyways".
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by rajin444 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:45PM (#33823298)
> Did they ignore them, or were they just not devaluing the lives of the sick and elderly?

Not devaluing the lives of the elderly is implicitly devaluing the lives of the not elderly. This is a trade off that was given almost no consideration in the greater (US) discussion.

> They do tho. Maybe not 100%, but to a degree they certainly do.

The degree is extremely important here. Without a certain level of transmission prevented this benefit becomes nonexistent. See grandpa enough times and he’ll catch it. That you don’t know the degree but still felt safe seeing him is very concerning and you were likely mislead.

> Not even sure what you're saying here.

Choosing to focus on masks and vaccines while ignoring obesity removes are principled arguments for the former. The latter has benefits both against future pandemics of all kinds as well as broad public health benefits. Thus, anyone not raising hell about how fat America is while advocating for forced vaccination and mask wearing is playing politics and not really interested in public health outcomes.

Like you, people claimed forced vaccinations were justified by externalities - but the same logic was not applied to forced weight loss.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by moistly on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:06AM (#33827032)
As if forcing weight loss could have happened fast enough to be useful.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by rajin444 on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:15AM (#33832475)
The benefits apply to more than just Covid and if maintained for the rest of a persons life. It’s a higher up front linear cost with an exponentially higher payout.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by mattdmrs on Friday December 02, 2022 @06:42PM (#33838493)
How do you even force weight lost?
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by BobbyJo on Friday December 02, 2022 @02:11PM (#33835288)
> Not devaluing the lives of the elderly is implicitly devaluing the lives of the not elderly. This is a trade off that was given almost no consideration in the greater (US) discussion.

It did though. We are going back to normal for the most part, despite the continuing risk to the elderly. Early lockdown was for everyone since very little was known about the disease.

> Choosing to focus on masks and vaccines while ignoring obesity removes are principled arguments for the former.

It's an obvious matter of practicality. Masks are easy and fast and will, statistically, do more good than a country wide weight loss drive. Would it be better long term if the country was fit? Yeah, for far more reasons than COVID. That's not practical though, as evidenced by the governments pre-existing desire and failure to make that happen.

> Like you, people claimed forced vaccinations were justified by externalities - but the same logic was not applied to forced weight loss.

Which is completely consistent with the state of the world pre-covid?