News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by lapcat on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:12AM (#33815780)
> If most of the deaths were in the elderly, Covid simply accelerated their death by X years.

"simply"?

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by smeej on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:29AM (#33815953)
Ultimately isn't that what any cause of death does? "Accelerate death" from whenever the second-worst thing you had going on would have gotten you?

I think I get what the parent comment was going for (i.e., that it only moved the date of death a little bit, as opposed to how the death of an otherwise healthy child would imply a date of death that moved a lot), but it's a weird way to say it.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by bvhvhfcgxfdf on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:24AM (#33815876)
Yeah this is the problem I have with COVID discourse. Simply no regard for elderlies because they don't dominate the pop culture discussion. They way we have sacrificed our older people to COVID will be one of the worst atrocities commited in human history.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by badcppdev on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:24AM (#33815873)
I was trying to write a reply to call out the use of that word. People need to be more careful with their language.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by zaroth on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:27AM (#33815924)
All causes of death “simply” accelerated another subsequent cause of death.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by conductr on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:56AM (#33816230)
It’s difficult to talk about some subjects online when people are so keen to mince other people’s words like this. They obviously meant nothing by it and you’re letting pedantry invalidate the point they were making. I’d prefer if you’d lower your editorial expectations for casual internet discussions more than I’d prefer everyone edit their word choices so carefully (unrealistic expectation honestly).

Not meant to pick on you, this is a common thing I see when certain topics are discussed but it does not benefit the discussion at all.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by giraffe_lady on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:56AM (#33817007)
Maybe the point was that they should have meant something by it. We're talking about death and misery on an immense scale, and certainly many of the people reading any comment here will have been affected, will be sitting alone reading this when they otherwise wouldn't. Is it so awful to ask people to consider that, to weigh their words carefully, given this context?
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by conductr on Thursday December 01, 2022 @10:02AM (#33817094)
Or yet another possibility is “simply” meant that the concept of people dying earlier than they otherwise would have is just an easy to grep concept most laymen can understand and thus a simple concept to discuss. If only.

This is a leaky medium for communication. It’s fast and casual and only text. Over analyzing each word is fine, but if you don’t like the word choice just move on. Trying to educate people to communicate how you want them to is a losing battle.

Also this node of the conversation is about data and analytics and now pedantry more than the underlying topic of death.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @06:38AM (#33829218)
Pedantry is about minor errors. I think it is careless to refer to millions of deaths like that.

But we might be coming with different expectations. This might be a serious discussion or it might be a casual internet discussion. Do you agree that if it's serious then people should be more careful with their words?

And if it's casual then are you complaining that I've strayed off topic?

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by refurb on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:20AM (#33816525)
You’d make a poor healthcare statistician getting upset over words like that.

Does it upset you the UK government values a year of human life at about 30,000 GBP?

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by lapcat on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:54AM (#33816980)
Where do you get "upset" from one word in quotation marks, followed by a question mark?

It was an invitation for clarification about what you meant.

How would you distinguish Covid from, say, murder, which also accelerates deaths by X years?

It's true that if the death rate is higher now, then the death rate may be lower in the future, but I'm not sure that's a useful way of thinking. If the death rate were 100% now, then the death rate would be 0% in the future. It all balances out, right? Except, that's not the way it works, because the dead never get their years or lives back.

We're all mortal and will eventually die sooner or later. But in most cases, later is much better than sooner.

I'd also mention that you probably wouldn't appreciate having 30,000X GBP stolen from you.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by refurb on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:52PM (#33825326)
You seem to be missing the point.

Sure, years of life are lost, but what kind of years? Someone in an old age home near the end of their life dying isn’t equivalent to a young child dying.

You can make good public health policy without measuring the gains and costs of any particular policy.

Saying “were going to save every single life no matter what” is a path to ruin.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by lapcat on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:05PM (#33825800)
> You seem to be missing the point.

> Sure, years of life are lost, but what kind of years?

No, I understand your point very well now. It is what I always thought it was.

Someday you may feel differently. If you live long enough, you may finally understand. But then it'll be too late, and the generations younger than you will also want to send you on "Logan's Run".

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by refurb on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:29PM (#33826795)
Now you're not even arguing in good faith.

Usually you need to argue for a better theory than what's being done, not make quip remarks about a movie.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by lapcat on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:53AM (#33830396)
> Now you're not even arguing in good faith.

I'm not even arguing, either in good or bad faith.

How do you argue with someone who places no value on the lives of older people? My intention was, and still is, to end this conversation.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by refurb on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:24AM (#33831684)
You’re definitely not arguing in good faith with the personal attacks.
Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by lapcat on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:45AM (#33832021)
Where's the personal attack?

I suspected that you had a certain view, so I prompted you to clarify your view, and you did indeed clarify your view:

> Sure, years of life are lost, but what kind of years? Someone in an old age home near the end of their life dying isn’t equivalent to a young child dying.

By your own words, you devalue the lives of older people.

I think it was good for everyone to see what you really believe, but I don't expect to be able to change your mind, so there's nothing to argue.

The only "personal attack" in this thread was:

> You’d make a poor healthcare statistician getting upset over words like that.

Re:Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @06:47AM (#33829287)
Healthcare statisticians would get upset with the careless use of that word. And they would call it out if used in a professional context.