1) We generally know the strength of the placebo effect and the rate of HIV transmission among at-risk groups, so we can control for it, and
2) Not sure the placebo effect is particularly relevant. First, a vaccine that shows little to no benefit over the control (placebo or not) is not an effective vaccine. Second, placebos aren't effective for everything. I highly doubt the effectiveness of a placebo at preventing HIV transmission (although it would be difficult to test ethically).
It would be unethical to give a placebo to someone for this kind of disease.
If you knew that it would be "unethical to give a placebo to someone" then you wouldn't have to do the trial!
Indeed - there have been situations in which the Trial turns out to be so positive - that the study is canceled, and all participants are given the treatment. I think that was actually the situation with the circumcision trials - circumcision turned out to be so ludicrously low risk, and so effective at reducing HIV infections in heterosexual male populations in Africa, that they, ethically, had to prematurely end the study and circumcise all the participants.
The University of Rochester has also been working on HIV vaccines for many years. They're always recruiting subjects. The posters are interesting because you can see what stage this particular vaccine is at based on who they're looking for. If they're looking for married, middle-age straight non-injection-drug-users, it's safety trial. If they're looking for young single MSMs or injection drug users, then you know that vaccine has progressed to the efficacy trials.
http://www.rochestervictoryalliance.org/
The 'non-vaccinated' group he speaks of is the placebo group. The reason he mentions it 'head off' anyone assuming they would test it by exposing people to HIV.
But more interestingly, why would it be "highly unethical" to do so? They're practicing informed consent, so everyone who gets a shot knows that there's only a 50% chance that they got the real vaccine. And they know that the vaccine isn't guaranteed to work (quite the opposite, in fact, based on the track record of similar trials here in the States).
"There is no placebo group" vs "Half the sample population gets the treatment half of it doesn't"
The "doesn't" is the placebo group.
And since every single other HIV vaccine has failed, it's likely that this one will also - so it's not like they are withholding an effective treatment and acting "highly unethical".
Medicine and social sciences have a large body of research about things like the fact that you can't do a pure experiment with a control group if there's serious risks.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_of_quasi-experiments
The seminal work (which I slogged through once upon a time): http://www.amazon.ca/Experimental-Quasi-Experimental-Designs...
So I was going to ask how clinical trials for vaccines are done, and this part kind of answers it, but now I'm curious - if there's no control group that gets a placebo injection, how do you control for the fact that people may behave differently if they think they've been given an anti-HIV vaccine? Unless I'm misreading this and "non-vaccinated" means placebo.