Unfortunately, as many posters here are pointing out, there's plenty of ways to do a correct-looking analysis of the data to get evidence to support your agenda.
Maybe your agenda is right and maybe it's not, but I'd love to hear a story of someone standing up and saying "your consultant submitted a report with glaring flaws, they should not be paid and you should reconsider X." It's more likely the little company just goes out of business or the big company buries the failure.
A typical VP will have an MBA and maybe took statistics in high school.
I've heard it a lot in situations where somebody is demanding a level of rigor that they themselves do not live up to. This is usually soon after they have framed the conversation around a solution that they want to pursue that also lacks any supporting data. That is to say, being data driven is on net good but it can also just be a thinly veiled appeal to status quo bias (which is itself not a terrible heuristic) or "highest-paid-person-in-the-room" bias.
I am not talking about in the instance of claim verification. I have seen a number of instances where a leader just wants to see data. Not any specific data, just all of the data. There is a belief that data can solve problems if only they had enough of it.