News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:04AM (#33787076)
You mean spam blocking? That is literally censorship.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by datadata on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:28AM (#33787288)
Censorship = you can't say X at all

Spam Blocking = you can't say X more than Y times

While technically censorship, there is a big difference, I think. Obviously in practice spam blocking could maliciously or accidentally be used for censorship.

Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by williamtrask on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:47AM (#33787476)
When Y==1 (such as an email spam blocker) then you proved their point.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by datadata on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:01AM (#33787648)
Why would Y==1 for email spam? In spam, the same message is sent many times. Entropy to try to make spam messages different is generally merely meant to. circumvent spam blockers.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:46AM (#33788964)
Spam is not illegal. Blocking non-illegal speech is censorship. End of story. There is no argument around this. Any conditions you place on it are arbitrary and are just you saying certain things are acceptable and others are not -- which is the definition of censorship.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by datadata on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @12:13PM (#33790258)
Genuinely trying to understand your beliefs here. When you say "Any conditions you place on it are arbitrary" does that also apply to the laws around speech themselves? For example if spam was made illegal, would it then (according to you) not be censorship to block spam?

My belief is that illegal speech is also still a form of censorship, just one that we are OK with. And that spam is more like a denial of service attack. Blocking spam is not about blocking the expression of an idea, but making sure that a communication channel is not abused as to make the channel ineffective.

Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:53PM (#33791576)
I am making a point that people who decry 'free speech / no censorship' have not thought it through to its logical conclusion. By telling a private entity such as twitter to 'remove all forms of censorship' then you are asking them to open the floodgates to every form of non-illegal speech. (I note illegal for obvious reasons because you have no discretion on removing illegal speech such as CSAM, you are obligated to do it).

'Remove all censorship' means not just 'free speech I want other people to have to deal with regardless of context' but also 'free speech that annoys the fuck out of me regardless of context', which very much includes spam.

By 'any conditions you place on it are arbitrary' I am referring specifically to 'if y is greater than x then spam else not spam'. That is arbitrary; you made that up. There is no 'if repeated more than once' appended to the end of "to suppress or delete as objectionable" in merriam webster under 'censor'. If you make up a rule to suite your convenience it is arbitrary.

Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by datadata on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:56PM (#33792398)
Got it. I agree my proposed rule is arbitrary. I also think twitter must have some form of spam prevention-- any kind of API rate limit would be by your definition be censorship also. I think you might be assuming I think twitter could or should strive to be censorship free, I don't think this is desirable or possible.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:23PM (#33792755)
> I think you might be assuming I think twitter could or should strive to be censorship free, I don't think this is desirable or possible.

Read the first sentence again of my last post. I am responding to a sentiment, not to you individually.

Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:51AM (#33787517)
I don't consent to receiving spam, so I don't mind if it's censored. I also self-censor my timeline aggressively by silencing, unfollowing and blocking accounts I don't like.

I only dislike censorship when they don't ask me first.

Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by realgeniushere on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:58AM (#33787599)
In the government context, this problem is very aptly dealt with by distinguishing “content neutrality” from “viewpoint neutrality”. That’s why the government can punish spam emailers without violating the first amendment.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:46AM (#33788974)
Twitter is not the government.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by realgeniushere on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:44PM (#33793026)
What a low effort and low thought reply. No one said it is. I’m saying there’s a principled way to have free speech and still take down spam.
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by Eisenstein on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:59PM (#33796478)
I'm sorry, please clarify. What does the 'government aspect' have to do with 'twitter removing other forms of censorship'? What is 'content neutrality' and how is it different from 'viewpoint neutrality'? How does pointing out that 'censoring' in regards to removing objectionable content by a corporation relate to the first amendment at all, and what does being 'principled' have to do with it?
Re:Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading in... by realgeniushere on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:45PM (#33820679)
Maybe this is more productive: What point were you trying to make with your spam comment? And how isn’t it addressed by twitter abiding by viewpoint neutrality but not content neutrality?