While I mentioned reminders often as it's easiest to describe, "Teach me something new." is exactly right. Engaging mailers should offer help, tips and such.
That's precisely what I did with my Gmail account when it became near-unusable after I used for several signups for startup services which I eventually was not interested in - just signed up to try out. Someone send me an email that does not pay me back with something useful for the minute of the attention I spend reading it - I create a filter to send it to 'adware' folder, which rarely, if ever, gets read.
This is of course my personal behavior, which may or may not be more typical.
But more than that - in more than one case my attempt to unsubscribe gave zero results. Once I even had an exchange with a human person, who promised "oh of course we will remove me". And that did not happen. So why would I invest my time into further attempts ? I'll just use the solution that works.
I don't need an email every time a small feature is released, or pushing me to come back... there's a reason I don't revisit, and it's not because I forgot. What I like are emails that give me something of value whether it's free content, a story, a free tip, etc. Teach me something new.