News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by mkl95 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:24AM (#33785393)
> Q: Shouldn't gov.uk just stick to domains under .gov.uk?(!) Would make it easier to work out who's actually gov.uk and who's merely pretending :)

The main reason to buy those domains is to spend as little money as possible. Someone at gov.uk is a cheapskate or works with a really limited budget.

Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by danw1979 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:32AM (#33785456)
Aren’t gov.uk domains transferred internally within UK government depts at zero cost ?

I guess there’s got to be some incentive for teams to not register hundreds of subdomains, but if they are turning to 3rd party TLDs to host government assets, I’d say something has gone wrong.

Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by mkl95 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:35AM (#33785863)
If the process is complex (write a detailed ticket, wait for feedback, get some manager's nod, etc.), buying a domain and deploying it yourself is orders of magnitude cheaper and faster, and can be the only way to test something in an env that resembles prod. I have done it myself for non critical stuff, although I'm not sure I would at some government org.
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by logifail on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:12AM (#33786560)
> If the process is complex (write a detailed ticket, wait for feedback, get some manager's nod, etc.), buying a domain and deploying it yourself is orders of magnitude cheaper and faster [..]

Isn't this basically the very definition of "shadow IT"?

Then you find that some prod[-ish] service relies on an external provider that's not listed as a provider in any of your org's financial systems, is paid by some random internal person's credit card and expensed back ... then that internal person leaves, and N weeks/months later all hell breaks loose when your service falls over and no-one knows why.

Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by mkl95 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:32AM (#33786746)
Most non SOC certified companies have some non auditable processes, the ubiquitous one being deploying stuff manually / non reproducibly. Whether something is "shadow IT" will depend on who you ask. Personally I have never deployed something to prod that way (I did it for some lower envs), but it's something I've seen people do at every single place I've worked. And your last paragraph is 100% true in my experience.
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by selfhoster11 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:33AM (#33785466)
This might sound a bit crazy, but... the UK government is in sole control of .gov.uk, right? They shouldn't have issues issuing themselves with as many subdomains as needed. For free, or for symbolic prices.
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by ldjb on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:33AM (#33785856)
Sort of. The UK Government (specifically the Cabinet Office) manages various aspects of the *.gov.uk space, but .gov.uk domains can be registered not only by the UK Government, but also local governments and other public sector organisations.

.gov.uk domains are registered through commercial registrars (who charge a fee), much like .co.uk domain names. The main difference being that you need to be an eligible organisation to register a .gov.uk domain name.

Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by IndigoIncognito on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:26AM (#33785402)
Limited budget, the UK public sector funding right now is atrocious, even in IT
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by robertlagrant on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:31AM (#33785443)
Not at this level. There are still roomfulls of people that cost more than the amount of money they're deciding whether or not to spend.
Re:Incident report: Some GOV.UK URLs blocked by deceptive si... by scrollaway on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:29AM (#33785824)
Absolutely untrue. The main reason these domains get bought is because it’s simpler.

There are likely procedures in place and security checks and people involved in gov.uk domain control, that are a non issue if the team owns the tld, which makes internal testing easier.