News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by bryan0 on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:52PM (#33783109)
But I don’t want a veggie patty. I want a hamburger that doesn’t involve killing animals. Beyond/Impossible is close enough.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by PankajGhosh on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:06PM (#33783212)
Understood that you dont; But before Beyond/Impossible came, there used to be veggie patty that vegetarians enjoyed. And many of them have never tasted meat, and don't want to eat something that tastes like meat.

OP's point is that Beyond/Impossible replaced the veggie patty with a non-meat version of meat patty, instead of adding a new item in the menu.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by JohnFen on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:31PM (#33783370)
And, honestly, as a meat-eater I really enjoy certain veggie patties. It's not meat, but it shouldn't be. They're their own delicious thing.

When I'm in the mood for a veggie burger, I don't want a hamburger. Restaurants shouldn't replace veggie patties with imitation meat -- they should have both.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by dkarl on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:55PM (#33783512)
Heck yeah. It's like pasta primavera and pasta bolognese. If you want one, you're not going to be happy with the other.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:03AM (#33786045)
The thing some vegetarians do not understand is that traditional cuisine from all over the World is basically 90% vegetarian, because poor people had to survive too.

I'm Italian, I could eat vegetarian meals everyday for a month without ever eating the same thing twice.

Same goes for all of Europe, Asia, Middle East, Africa or South America.

Vegetable dishes are the foundation of every established culinary tradition.

There's absolutely no need for incredible|magical|impossible|whatever meat.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by valarauko on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:12PM (#33791794)
> The thing some vegetarians do not understand is that traditional cuisine from all over the World is basically 90% vegetarian, because poor people had to survive too.

You're saying that vegetarians don't know this?

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:59AM (#33797481)
> You're saying that vegetarians don't know this?

Arguably some don't.

Read again: some.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by valarauko on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:00PM (#33803604)
Sure, some people of every ilk are likely to be uninformed about some aspect of the world or the other. How does that apply in the current context? Most meals for most people worldwide are essentially vegetarian, even if the people are not obligate vegetarians. Are there some vegetarians unfamiliar with the reality of practically all world cuisines? Sure - and? Impossible meats aren't directed towards these people, and they aren't looking to substitute the taste of a burger. They're likely not averse to it, for what it's worth.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Thursday December 01, 2022 @06:08AM (#33814823)
> Sure, some people of every ilk are likely to be uninformed about some aspect of the world or the other

I am absolutely not claiming that, I am absolutely claiming that beliefs based on feelings and not hard truths tend to reject rational arguments, hence their members are usually not the most curious people around and it's common they ignore things that are obvious to the rest of us.

Take a western vegetarian, we all know a few of them and some vegan too.

Most vegetarians/vegan inform themselves in vegetarian communities, which are based on the same western principles where they were born, mainly North America.

Most vegetarian communities are based on spurious correlations, like the fact that 80% of people from India are Hinduists, a religion that promotes a lacto-vegetarian diet letting people believe that 80% of Indians are vegetarians, which is obviously completely false.

Christianity promotes a mostly vegetarian diet too, there's a list of food that you should not consume on certain days, nobody follows those prescriptions anymore, they are thousands years old and come from the Jewish traditions.

But if I say that 30% of the World population is Christian, a religion that promotes a mostly vegetarian diet, things sound completely different.

Don't also forget that in vegetarian circles meat is the root cause of everything bad: from cancer[1] to diabetes[2], deforestation[3], being overweight [4], depression[5] and even infertility[6] (yes, you heard right!)

All these claims have been either debunked, highly exaggerated or correlated when there is no factual evidence. Yet they resist in the narrative of these communities, like the idea that Christ died on a cross and then came back to life 3 days later. It's false, we know it is, but people still believe it and there's nothing we can do about it.

It's easy to understand the stigma that these manipulatory lies can create around "traditional food", these people often think of themselves as revolutionary going against the status quo, so their enemy are their local traditions, not just the meat (everyone eats some meat around them, so it must be "the others their ways and they do not see it").

So they end up eating a lot of food that is not local nor traditional (tradition equals bad, remember?), such as tofu, that in Italy is totally not traditional nor commonly used, yet most vegetarians and vegans rely on it.

The reason why?

Vegetarianism in the west is a business, if you can sell the dirty cheap tofu at 5-10 euros/kg (that's the price in Italy) while poultry costs 3-5 euros/kg (raw, raised on the ground and antibiotic free) you can understand how convenient it is to sell people the idea that you need to eat tofu instead of pasta with tomato sauce (1-1.5 euros/kg), you are in for the big bucks.

Don't dismiss what I say just because you disagree, I've researched the topic a lot, this is just the tip of the iceberg.

> Most meals for most people worldwide are essentially vegetarian, even if the people are not obligate vegetarians

Sooner or later people in the west will understand that there are people among us priding themselves for not eating meat while our pets, for example cats, every year eat 10 times the meat an average central African person has to eat, suffering the horrendous consequences of malnutrition, like watching their children die of hunger or curable disease that their bodies weakened by the forced plant based diet hadn't the strength to fight, and we don't see a problem with that.

The irony is that those people are in developing countries, they are developing, they will eventually eat more meat, no way they will keep dying for a made up belief, for those who care about animal suffering I have an advice: renounce to pets. They eat too much meat, they kill too many animals, they are not sustainable.

[1] https://thetruthaboutcancer.com/cancer-causing-foods-2/

[2] https://www.peta.org/issues/animals-used-for-food/diabetes/

[3] https://thehumaneleague.org/article/meat-industry-deforestat...

[4] https://www.peta.org/issues/animals-used-for-food/obesity/

[5] https://psychcentral.com/depression/foods-that-cause-depress...

[6] https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/foods-to-avoid-when-try...

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by valarauko on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:11PM (#33822824)
I think you're conflating the median North American vegetarian with the median vegan. Your comment makes a lot more sense if I substitute "vegan" for wherever you've used "vegetarian". If you do indeed mean "vegetarian", then I think it makes much less sense in contemporary America, for example.

Yes, almost every vegan I've known is optimizing to minimize animal "cruelty", defined on their own ideological terms. Meanwhile, almost every vegetarian I've known is either one for religious reasons (and have their tradition's cultural cuisines to draw from) or simply don't like meat. I also know many Muslims who avoid meat at restaurants since it's not halal. I am struggling to recall any vegetarians that eat an average American diet by simply replacing meat with something like tofu.

If your intent is indeed to refer to vegetarians, I think that hasn't been the case in the US since perhaps the 90s. American vegetarianism really took off in the cultural context of the 60s and 70s, where Eastern ideas & sensibilities were imported but not the people or their cuisines. If a median American in the 70s wanted to maintain a meat free diet, their options were genuinely restricted. That's certainly not the case now, where the median American vegetarian is likely of recent immigrant descent, and has their heritage cuisine to inspire vegetarian meals. Changes to American immigration policy and the segment of countries where immigrants have come from have changed American vegetarianism. I also think something like Impossible burgers have very little appeal to the median vegetarian, since they're not interested in the taste of meat to begin with.

Yes, unlike the median American vegetarian, the median American vegan tends to appear spontaneously among families that are not themselves vegan. Unlike vegetarians, they don't have a rich family tradition to draw from, and plenty learn to just wing it. That said, I do think even this is likely not the case anymore. Today, in any big city, good vegan/vegetarian food is easy to find. As an illustrative example, I asked a relative who's lived in NYC for 40 years what his favorite restaurant meal has been (he absolutely loves steak). His favorite restaurant is a vegan Korean BBQ. Similarly, I've been informed by Mexicans of an amazing Mexican vegan place in Brooklyn.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by dkarl on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:51PM (#33783494)
I love a good veggie patty burger. I also like the Impossible burger. I'd love to see both on a menu so I can choose the one I want. And heck I'll eat a meatburger on special occasions as well. There are a couple of local restaurants that had really nicely done veggie patties that have been displaced by Beyond/Impossible burgers, and it's a shame.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by wtetzner on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @12:41AM (#33784081)
Unfortunately I doubt Beyond/Impossible don’t involve killing animals.
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:55AM (#33786004)
> But I don’t want a veggie patty. I want a hamburger that doesn’t involve killing animals

so basically you want a veggie patty disguised as an hamburger.

but there's a catch: agriculture kills as many animals than we do to eat them.

You might not see them, but billions of insects, worms, small rodents etc are killed in the process of making agriculture a viable business.

Pesticides are not exactly environmental friendly.

But then the crops need to be protected from their natural predators: herbivores!

You might have asked yourself sometimes why we don't see deers, boars, jackrabbits, cows, goats (the list is endless) roaming free close to crop fields and the answer is simple: they eat the crops, so they have been killed in the past and are now kept away, maybe not shooting them directly, but not asking gently either.

That causes massive repercussions on natural fauna too: coyotes, wolves, bears, cougars, bobcats etc cannot survive in absence of preys.

So basically veggie patties are not made of dead animals, but a lot of animals died so that we could eat them.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by sweetheart on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:41AM (#33786846)
Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:25AM (#33787948)
I am aware of the objections coming from vegans, I really have nothing to say to them other than I am in favour of freedom of worship, but I am also an atheist who tries to stand on the side of the scientific method as much as my abilities allow me, so I think National Geographic and PNAS are a more reliable source of information.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/insec...

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2023989118

Most importantly: loss of vegetable specie due to mono cultures farmed specifically for humans (tomatoes for burgers, for example - McDonald's is one of the biggest, if not THE biggest, purchaser in the world of potatoes, lettuce and tomatoes - or avocados for fancy sandwiches, that consume 300 liters of water to produce a single fruit) is not be underestimated.

As an example, this sentence

> vegans are inflicting far less damage because most of the cereal crops that are mono-cropped (wheat, corn, soy, etc.) are fed to the animals people consume.

is almost completely made up.

The reason why original Parmigiano cheese is so worshipped by Italians and it's so expensive abroad, is exactly because cows are not fed with crops, bu with natural grass.

The reason why in USA many animals are fed with farmed crops is because crops are subsidized by the govt, making them cheaper than the alternatives.

Another reason why herbivores are sometimes fed with crop is because they can eat the remains we don't eat which is around 85% of the plant in the case of wheat. *

* https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5caca181348cd9...

According to FAO (United Nations Agency for food) "only 13% of global animal feed (all animals for food, including chickens, pigs and cattle) is comprised of grain crops"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S22119...

Crops are also heavily subsidized to produce bio fuel, which is not great, I agree, but that has nothing to do with feeding animals or eating their meat.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by sweetheart on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @11:26AM (#33789592)
I don't think any of the sources you mentioned here actually justify animal agriculture on the grounds of causing less death, though. The first two sources aren't specific to agriculture specific to human consumption, just agriculture in general. Also, whether or not global livestock is primarily fed on human consumable crops isn't the issue. For example, a very large portion of the feed mentioned in one of your sources (the third one) is still coming from farmed crops, so even if it isn't human consumable that doesn't mean we don't consider deaths coming from it. The last source is just unrelated, as you acknowledge.

I think you'd need to have sources that prove that specifically crops grown for human consumption result in more deaths, or that we'd have to grow more of those crops to feed humans compared to the crops grown to feed animals.

Again, just to clarify, the third source you mention has categories for things like "by-products", "Other non-edible", "Oil seed cakes", etc. Whether or not humans can eat those is irrelevant. The point is that all those things could still be coming from crops grown in the same general way as the crops grown for human consumption. Does that make sense, or am I being too religious for your logical atheistic brain?

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by peoplefromibiza on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:56AM (#33797465)
> I think you'd need to have sources that prove that specifically crops grown for human consumption

I think you don't understand the issue.

Vegetarians (and vegans) don't kill less animals, they simply don't eat them (or at least that's what they say...)

> The point is that all those things could still be coming from crops

The point is that eating meat, unless you are from the US, does not mean you're killing billions of animals for fun.

American domestic cats kill billion of birds and other small animals every year.

Why are vegetarians obsessed only with non vegetarian people and not with domestic cats, which they love?

Because it's a religious fight, not an ethical one.

They want to blame someone and found this.

Anyway: scientific method implies that if you say "vegetarians kill less animals" you should prove it with numbers, as humans their activities kill billion of animals every year all over the World.

Vegetarians are not outside of the human realm, they live in societies as we all do and the major source of animal killing and suffering is not eating some meat, that's only selection bias at work.

It would be the same as saying: plants produce oxygen, if you only eat plants you're robbing our planet of breathable air, you should replant every plant you eat.

But every normal well functioning human knows that it's stupid to divide people into good and bad.

That's exactly what vegetarians do.

If you believe in veganism, it's OK, religions are allowed in our societies.

If you believe "vegan facts" from a vegan website is the truth, I don't know what to say to you, you can't fight made up beliefs, I got the Pope in front of my house, I know you can't beat blind faith.

But, the claim has always been that vegetarians don't kill less animals, not that they kill more. Which is arguably true. You won't find vegans in poor countries, you'll find denutrished children starving to death, they'd eat some meat if they could, just to survive. Veganism is a first World problem and as many other first World problems it's completely disconnected from reality.

When you'll eat an entire plant of wheat from roots to the top, we can talk about eating only vegetables.

Until that day you are only wasting resources, as any western human does so well.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by sweetheart on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:41AM (#33831949)
> Vegetarians (and vegans) don't kill less animals

Source? Your claim, thus the onus is on you to prove this, which you haven't.

> American domestic cats kill billion of birds and other small animals every year.

Completely irrelevant whataboutism. Like, that's a textbook example of the fallacy.

> Vegetarians are not outside of the human realm, they live in societies as we all do and the major source of animal killing and suffering is not eating some meat, that's only selection bias at work.

> It would be the same as saying: plants produce oxygen, if you only eat plants you're robbing our planet of breathable air, you should replant every plant you eat.

I don't even know how to respond to this. If we include fish, then _trillions_ of animals are killed every year for their meat and body parts. How is that not the greatest source of animal suffering?

> If you believe in veganism, it's OK, religions are allowed in our societies.

This is such a lazy insult. Why do you insist on acting like you argue in good faith, yet say nonsense like this? Genuinely, why?

> You won't find vegans in poor countries, you'll find denutrished children starving to death, they'd eat some meat if they could, just to survive. Veganism is a first World problem and as many other first World problems it's completely disconnected from reality.

What is the point you're making here, exactly? Because some people in the world have limited access to non-animal based sources of nutrition then veganism as an ethical framework is entirely debunked. How on Earth does that follow?

Your style of debate is _not_ working, my guy. Your comment history in other threads seems to paint a picture of you not really arguing in good faith. If you want to continue this discussion, I'll only do it on a video call. My email is in my profile if you'd like to set that up.

Re:Beyond Meat Is Struggling, and the Plant-Based Meat Indus... by bryan0 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:38AM (#33788850)
I appreciate the very good points you are making, however I do not consider these morally equivalent. Specifically the indirect affects of agriculture on local wildlife vs direct and largely unnecessary killing and suffering of animals.