News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by quickthrower2 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:27AM (#33761404)
He didn’t answer the question the first come to my mind: Is the curve from the physical spline a bezier?
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by samwillis on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:29AM (#33761416)
You should be able to describe (within any reasonable tolerance) the same curve with a bezier, however the control points will obviously be different.

Any imperfections in the physical spline, say a knot of it's wooden, would translate to a slight curvature difference.

Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by quickthrower2 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @04:41AM (#33761694)
Sounds like the physical curves are a subset of bezier? So there might be some bezier curves that cannot be replicated physically
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by samwillis on Sunday November 27, 2022 @04:47AM (#33761722)
Not really, you can just add more and more control points to a Bézier and it will be possible to describe a curve to a greater accuracy.

However, in reality when using Bézier curves you want to really want to use the minimum number of control point neccesery to ensure a nice smooth curve.

Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by quickthrower2 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @05:18AM (#33761859)
I mean vice versa. Can the physical thing do any CAD Bezier?
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by hamburglar on Sunday November 27, 2022 @06:41AM (#33762270)
A Bézier curve can have a cusp, which you can’t do with a physical spine.
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by Gordonjcp on Sunday November 27, 2022 @06:15AM (#33762156)
> Not really, you can just add more and more control points to a Bézier and it will be possible to describe a curve to a greater accuracy.

The more control points you add to your curve the more computationally expensive it becomes, though.

This is just the law of spline demand.

Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by Jarmsy on Sunday November 27, 2022 @07:58AM (#33762669)
Excellently integrated pun!
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by mech765 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @05:19AM (#33761862)
IIRC, generally speaking a beam with a transverse point load (think like a diver on the tip of a diving board) deforms into a parabolic curve, and beams with more point loads end up taking higher order polynomial curves. Engineering beam math usually much assumes that the beam is acting under small deflections though.

I don't remember as much about beziers but I think they are also often essentially a series of cubic curves. There are a couple of different types of splines- one of them is controlled locally only by it's local control points (I think that one's beziers) and one requires all control points to control the whole curve.

Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by Jarmsy on Sunday November 27, 2022 @07:44AM (#33762591)
That's incorrect. That curve is Bernoulli's elastica, which is different from a parabola (though for small deformations they can be a reasonably close approximation).
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by Jarmsy on Sunday November 27, 2022 @08:00AM (#33762679)
There is a neat connection between a rolling hyperbola and an elastica though: https://twitter.com/KangarooPhysics/status/14337538508177858...
Re:When Splines Were Physical Objects by Jarmsy on Sunday November 27, 2022 @07:40AM (#33762567)
No - it's an elastica, which cannot be represented exactly as a bezier. Raph Levien's thesis is a great read on this https://www.levien.com/phd/thesis.pdf