News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by FollowingTheDao on Saturday November 26, 2022 @06:43AM (#33751879)
In an artists chosen medium, there are constraints. For the painter, the paint; for the photographer, the subject.

It is the constraints that determine creativity.

With AI there are no constraints, so it is not art.

Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by corsac on Saturday November 26, 2022 @07:20AM (#33752056)
How are there no constraints with AI? I'm not arguing that this piece is good art, but rather that "AI" is merely a tool, with limitations like any other tool. In fact, considering how aesthetically uniform (centerless, fragmented, "dead") works using Midjourney and similar programs are, they strike me as extremely limited, little more than artistic crutches for producing novelties that will almost immediately become dated.
Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by FollowingTheDao on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:41PM (#33755331)
> "AI" is merely a tool, with limitations like any other tool.

What are the limitations?

The "deadness" you are feeling is not from AI's limitations, but from a lack of constraints. You have to think about this for it to sink in. I know it sounds un-intuative, but it is true. AI is nothing but a human given no constraints. The same thing is true in digital photography. Have you ever noticed how it all looks the same? There was a time this was much less true.

Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by corsac on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:14PM (#33759406)
> What are the limitations?

Inability to procedurally generate highly stochastic forms or textures (for instance what a haboku painter, or any kindergartner, can get by splattering paint); reliance on a finite bank of source or "training" images; no way for the artist to turn an artistic vision into a meaningful input for an I/O program; no demonstrated ability or proposed algorithm for producing on its own (without human inputs) anything most people would recognize as art.

> AI us nothing but a human given no constraints.

I think you have a key insight that productive constraints lie at the living core of the arts, and I agree that if some hypothetical entity that was a human with no constraints produced imaginative works, Kipling's devil[0] would finally get to make a point. I had a similar objection to the hype when AlphaGo beat Lee Sedol – Lee was playing under the constraints of (albeit remarkable) human cognition, which the "AI" with its sheer computing power did not even pretend to approximate, yet still did overall quite well.

But no existing or proposed AI is anything like "a human without constraints."

There are productive constraints, and their are counterproductive constraints. The 5-7-5 haiku form is a productive constraint; complete exclusion of the letter "e" from an novel[1] turned out to be an unproductive one. Having to include anything generated by Midjourney in an extremely unproductive constraint.

[0] https://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_conundrum.htm [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadsby_(novel)

Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by theRealMe on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:43AM (#33753029)
Paint isn’t the constraint of a painter. Imagination is. The same imagination that constrains AI prompting.

The value a person prescribed to a painting isn’t in how the painter was able to manipulate the paint, it’s in what the painting as a whole means to them.

Re:Art Made with Artificial Intelligence Wins at State Fair by FollowingTheDao on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:32PM (#33755250)
> Paint isn’t the constraint of a painter. Imagination is.

What can you paint, right now, at this moment, this second. Probably very little

Now what, at this same moment, can you imagine. Anything. You can imagine absolutely anything. Imagination is unlimited. Whether what is imagined is art or not is besides the point.

> The value a person prescribed to a painting isn’t in how the painter was able to manipulate the paint, it’s in what the painting as a whole means to them.

The craft does not matter? Only the content? How do you separate the craft from the content?