Re:Good news: Mozilla fixed their damn browser
by sciurus on Tuesday December 20, 2011 @09:09PM
(#3376087)
Calling it obsolete is hyperbole. A standard definition of obsolete is something that was once common but no longer is. Just last week I had to revert a number of ext4 filesystems back to ext3 due to performance problems on RHEL5, so I'm afraid that ext3 will be in common use for years to come.
(The performance problems aren't present in Fedora 16, so you could argue that RHEL5 is obsolete.)
Re:Good news: Mozilla fixed their damn browser
by CPlatypus on Wednesday December 21, 2011 @12:01AM
(#3376420)
Yes, the RHEL5 kernel is obsolete in that it lacks the barrier support necessary to implement proper behavior with decent performance. The fact that obsolete ext3 runs better on also-obsolete 2.6.18 kernels doesn't really tell us much except that sometimes two pieces of software evolve together, and sometimes versions that were developed together work better than versions that were not.
The problem is that, in ext3, not using data=ordered is also problematic - this time in terms of potential corruption and security issues. That's why even the people who brought you ext3 abandoned it years ago in favor of making ext4 do these things the right way. If you want reasonable fsync behavior, plus niceties like block-size awareness and trim/discard support, you need to use a modern filesystem.
A piece of software that embodies a broken approach to a solved problem is by definition obsolete, and that includes ext3. Please don't make claims about what's obsolete when you don't even understand the issues that would make it so.