The intent is to prohibit platforms from leveraging their greater capital reserves to purchase and permanently acquire (and platform-limit) those who make software, thereby decreasing competition between platforms and increasing profits.
There's never been an industry where this worked well for the consumer or society. See: ATT, IBM, Microsoft, Apple.
Apple has never had anywhere near a monopoly on any platform. AT&T had a government mandated monopoly.
What major software company has Apple acquired aside from NeXT?
But of course that buckled at various times (first with proto-Office vs 1-2-3 & WordPerfect, then with the 90s dominance / Encarta-era smorgasbord of random MS software).
Excel was released on Mac because Microsoft wasn't confident in directly challenging 1-2-3 (on DOS) or early-Windows capabilities. And ultimately, it was exactly the fact that Microsoft owned the OS that allowed them to dominate in office apps and browsers in the 90s/00s.
Apple has had a monopoly on two device platforms (iPods, then iOS) and has abused both of them to its own profit.
ATT didn't have a government mandated monopoly: it had a series of every-few-decades consent decrees in which it bargained with the US government to avoid being nationalized. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingsbury_Commitment
Apple has acquired a substantial amount of software and developers. They just tend to do so at the nascent product stage (vs Google and MS acquiring later). See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisit...
iOS is not a monopoly with 50%. We had a real judge during the Epic vs Apple case say as much.
Encarta was also available for the Mac.
The App Store is an absolute monopoly in the market of software sales on iOS devices.
That the court defined the relevant market otherwise isn't contradictory.
Antitrust law of 1890 just isn't well-suited for keeping modern globally networked platforms competitive.
Not sure how that is overly complicated? Or you or others shorten that to 'the court said the App Store wasn’t a monopoly'?
The court said a very different thing.
And yes, it should be illegal to sell physical devices with a non-user-selectable digital store.
A legal case is decided on the arguments brought, weighed against current law. It's not some black/white definition of universal truth.
The industry as a whole would be a lot better off if platform-studio vertical integration were banned, and strict financing-only co-ops set up as counterweights to EA/Activision accumulation.