Re:Apple scores limited victory in smartphone patent war
by Karunamon on Tuesday December 20, 2011 @10:30AM
(#3373741)
I'm pretty sure I saw that functionality in devices that existed long before the iPhone.. fucking patents.
But to be fair, an import blockade is a pretty solid victory. Unfortunately for Apple, HTC can release a software update to disable the "infringing" functionality and quite possibly reinvent it in a way that isn't infringing anything.
Re:Apple scores limited victory in smartphone patent war
by vidarh on Tuesday December 20, 2011 @12:16PM
(#3374204)
A blockade now would have been a solid victory. A blockade months into the future for a trivially disabled feature is pretty much a joke.
I worked on a touch pad in '99 that had this functionality, and I'm pretty sure we didn't come up with the idea.
Unfortunately we never got it into mass production, and I doubt sufficient details were released to use it as prior art. Nokia's Screen Phone might have had similar functionality.
(Search for FreePad if interested - still a few articles available)
But really? They have a patent for making telephone numbers in a document click-able to call that number? That seems so obvious a thing to do on a phone why grant the patent? Plus, if HTC can come up with a workaround so easily and quickly doesn't that also support the thought it's an overly obvious (i.e., useless) patent? Did I understand that part correctly?