No, not quite. Pure functional programming is a specific style or paradigm. It's about writing referential transparent expressions only. Tagging something is "impure" is absolutely not the same, even though doing so and/or separating pure and impure functions is a good first step on the way to pure functional programming.
> Who knows though. Maybe we'll see interesting things in Gleam in the future :)
Would be nice and might make me switch ecosystems. As of now, there don't seem to be concrete plans:
> Yes, Gleam is an impure functional language like OCaml or Erlang. Impure actions like reading to files and printing to the console is possible without special handling. > We may later introduce an effects system for identifying and tracking any impure code in a Gleam application, though this is still an area of research.
I don't entirely disagree, but I also don't think it would be a game changer for a couple reasons...
- It's already well established practice to separate pure and impure modules in Erlang/Elixir projects, even without a type system to enforce it. Take Ecto for instance, it has a clean split of side-effects (Ecto.Repo) and pure logic (Ecto.Changeset). Very different from things like ActiveRecord or Django ORM. [1]
- BEAM programs (and libraries) use a lot of concurrency and message passing, and I think you would have to use an escape hatch ala unsafePerformIO more often than a typical Haskell program, otherwise the IO would "infect" most of the code. Things like instrumentation, fetching app environment, calling the code server, using process dict...
Joe Armstrong kind of mentions the latter problem in his thesis [2]:
He is of course talking about "dirty" _modules_. Working at the function level, the leakage wouldn't be quite as bad... but I think it may still be enough to limit how useful IO annotations would be. Code that "has been written in such a way so that the side effects do not leak out" is quite common on BEAM.Who knows though. Maybe we'll see interesting things in Gleam in the future :)
[1] "To spawn, or not to spawn?" is a good article on the practice of separating I/O (GenServer) code and pure code: https://www.theerlangelist.com/article/spawn_or_not
[2] https://erlang.org/download/armstrong_thesis_2003.pdf